[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k] [cm / hm / y] [3 / adv / an / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / hc / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / po / pol / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / x] [rs] [status / ? / @] [Settings] [Home]
Board:  
Settings   Home
4chan
/tg/ - Traditional Games


File: 1374726303346.jpg-(332 KB, 900x1273, 1372315858214.jpg)
332 KB
332 KB JPG
Word to your birthing pod /tg/. I would like to discuss Soul Eater with you.

"What is the Soul Eater? Is it one of those Japanese Animes?" you say? First off; it was a manga first and you can read it here http://www.mangareader.net/157/soul-eater.html (p.s. it reads right to left) Second ; if you don't want to read no backwards comics you can watch the anime here http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n0nxQXTdu9c

Now, the setting of Soul Eater is PQ. It's kinda like our world, but with humans that can turn into weapons and the kitchen sink of Gothic Horror goodies with some Lovecraftian influences spread throughout. Now, if that hasn't caught your interest; it's kinda like if Harry Potter had a baby with Bleach and that baby was raised by Nightmare Before Christmas. It also has Maka (pictured in the foreground) It's good. Trust me.

With the introduction done, lets talk Soul Eater.
>>
>>26222942
Sure, OP.
Black Star is best shibusen
>>
File: 1374726890307.jpg-(128 KB, 1200x869, 037.jpg)
128 KB
128 KB JPG
>>26223170
Yessss. He will become bigger than God! So boss.
>>
File: 1374727625945.jpg-(242 KB, 1200x1516, sample-c30435feb8a9e307e0(...).jpg)
242 KB
242 KB JPG
Dang, /tg/ is running fast tonight.

Anybody care to speculate what will happen to Spartoi post defeating Ashura?

Am I the only one to think that Medusa ain't deaddead yet?
>>
>>26223592
The series feels like it's ending.
>>
File: 1374729037786.png-(100 KB, 543x302, cant deal.png)
100 KB
100 KB PNG
>>26224196
Yup. 1 chapter left. And I don't entirely know how to deal with it.
>>
File: 1374729374907.png-(98 KB, 550x366, 4b6f0de2a9556f6d7dd6df448(...).png)
98 KB
98 KB PNG
crazy maka bump
>>
are they still releasing chapters monthly? i hope there is still a dedicated translator group
>>
>>26224475
>>26224271
oh shit. i feel like they can keep going with the " Eight Powerful Warriors"
>>
File: 1374729667959.jpg-(189 KB, 753x1062, 1370577732153.jpg)
189 KB
189 KB JPG
>>26224475
yes http://reader.vortex-scans.com/reader/series/soul_eater/ does more recent stuff, and the link in the opening post has the older stuff.
>>
File: 1374729779815.jpg-(231 KB, 1280x1024, patches has opinions too.jpg)
231 KB
231 KB JPG
>>26224475
Pretty shitty manga
>>
>>26224598
Didn't mean to quote
>>
File: 1374729859110.jpg-(604 KB, 1600x1174, soul_eater___spartoi_by_c(...).jpg)
604 KB
604 KB JPG
>>26224557
Oh man how would love that. But the author, Atsushi Okubo, hasn't said anything on doing more Soul Eater. I don't even know how much more Soul Eater NOT he is scheduled to do.
>>
>>26224271
Wait, really? Who said there's one chapter left?
>>
File: 1374730977400.png-(209 KB, 600x592, 1369022409963.png)
209 KB
209 KB PNG
>>26224952
http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2013-06-06/soul-eater-manga-to-end-in-2-more-chapters

Best evidence i gots for you. I'm basically just parroting what i've heard in the past weeks.
>>
Soul Eater is really cool and I really want to work out how to do an RPG set in that world where the PCs can play meisters/weapons, but the issue is 'what does the weapon do in combat' keeps coming up and I'm not sure how to handle it.
>>
File: 1374731304934.png-(209 KB, 500x601, 1354322882663.png)
209 KB
209 KB PNG
>>26225176
Simple. No PC weapons. It does ruin late game potential, but allows for low level groups to not have to deal with 50% of the party being "pure support".
>>
File: 1374731352433.png-(759 KB, 1385x619, soul.png)
759 KB
759 KB PNG
Be amazed as I fix my biggest issue with Soul Eater in 30 seconds using Photoshop.
>>
>>26225287
That is actually a radically different face.
Atsushi's faces in the beginning were awful, they looked like they were melting.
>>
File: 1374731681644.jpg-(52 KB, 914x589, 1366875663990.jpg)
52 KB
52 KB JPG
I just want to mention
>using a scythe as a weapon
Unless it looks something like this, I shiggy.
>>
File: 1374731720139.jpg-(19 KB, 500x371, (ﺧ益ﺨ).jpg)
19 KB
19 KB JPG
>>26225414
Don't remind me of early Soul Eater. Just, uh.
>>
>>26225437
You object to that, but not to a dude using a pair of 92FSes UPSIDE DOWN?
>>
File: 1374731812566.png-(263 KB, 680x750, I don't want to deal(...).png)
263 KB
263 KB PNG
>>26225451
>>
Easily has some of the most obnoxious characters. If you're eleven you may enjoy the WHACKY OCD BADASS or LE BEING NINJA BUT NOT BEING SNEAKY XDD
>>
File: 1374731853425.jpg-(19 KB, 161x999, 1366875398787.jpg)
19 KB
19 KB JPG
>>26225474
That isn't half the images in this thread, anon.
>>
>>26225437
unmodified for war scythes saw a lot of peasant use because it was a blade on hand.

stop being a spergian faggot who forgets that the real world has never been as pragmatic and preplanned as your hardon wishes it was.
>>
File: 1374731907337.png-(285 KB, 2335x1418, 1372299952896.png)
285 KB
285 KB PNG
>>26225437
I mostly agree. At least it become more axe-like occasionally.

Also, scythe are cool and symbolic. Not practical, but look at Kid and his guns akimbo. Soul Eater ain't realistic.
>>
File: 1374731944597.jpg-(64 KB, 675x720, 1374720254012.jpg)
64 KB
64 KB JPG
What system would you run this in, my money's on fate, just because shenanigans you can have if your weapons have aspects
>>
How would a Soul Eater table-top play?

Meisters and weapons with sanity meters?
>>
>>26225568
Sanity meters are a must. But you must also have a MADNESS meter, because in Soul Eater it isn't a sliding scale. Madness is a power and you can be totally sane and completely MAD. Like Maka, sometimes.
>>
File: 1374732164421.jpg-(39 KB, 650x289, Swiss Saber.jpg)
39 KB
39 KB JPG
>>26225259
>No PC weapons
But what if I wanna play a Swiss Saber?
>>
>>26225534
No, not really.
Converting it was like a 5 minute job at a blacksmith, which any self-respecting peasant uprising had.
So yes, it was better than nothing, but if you did anything but run off straight from the field into a fight, you could easily make it much better than better than nothing.
>>
File: 1374732219272.jpg-(64 KB, 300x360, 1358741537504.jpg)
64 KB
64 KB JPG
>>26225557
>mfw that thread died
>>
>>26225687
It lives on in our hearts and the archives forever.
>>
File: 1374732428222.jpg-(223 KB, 1136x852, 1368403437199.jpg)
223 KB
223 KB JPG
>>26225670
Also I forgot my image.
Which isn't a scythe, but it looks sexy and I'm kind of drunk and I've got Yes playing and it's a little after midnight so whatever.
>>
I love the anime so far, FOOL!
>>
File: 1374732570106.png-(215 KB, 592x506, 1372831106459.png)
215 KB
215 KB PNG
>>26225668
Impressive. Well, Weaspons could control how 'intense' they are going. Like 'augmented weapon' 'normal weapon' (the mifune fight is an example of this). Assisting in stratagem. Possibly adding skill/damage.
>>
I remember trying to make a race that worked kinda like the Weapon people did for D&D a while back.

The stats changed completely depending on the weapon they turned into, which was determined by a set of 2 rolls. One for weapon type (Polearm, Sword, Double, Bow, Sling, etc.), one for actual weapon. It was... Difficult to handle, to say the least.

It also made me add a new mechanic, which was the Wavelength, which was determined by a single d% roll at character creation. I worked it like this.

1. If your wavelength is within 10 points of another non-Weapon character's wavelength, they can wield you as a weapon.
2. If your wavelength is within 5 points of another non-Weapon character's wavelength, they can wield you and unlock (Witch-hunter, Shadowstar, Death Cannon, whatever fit best with the weapon. Some of them I had to make up as I went along.)
3. If your wavelength is within 2 points of another non-Weapon character, they can wield you, use "Witch Hunter" or "Genie Hunter (Or Shieldstar, some other bullshit made for other weapons, whatever.).
4. If you and another non-Weapon character share a Wavelength, the non-Weapon character can wield you, use "Witch Hunter", "Genie Hunter", and "Kishin Hunter" (Or Enchanted Sword Mode. Or that ultimate Death Cannon thing. Or whatever I decided would work for a mace, quarterstaff, dagger, or whatever the fuck weapon you turn into.)

I scrapped the idea after a while. It just wasn't working as well as I'd hoped.
>>
File: 1374732672133.jpg-(79 KB, 527x702, Svardstav.jpg)
79 KB
79 KB JPG
>>26225668
Maybe it should just be "Only one player per Meister/Weapon pair", with the player controlling both halves of the duo during combat, but only their character outside of it?
Personally if I was gonna be a Weapon I'd go with a Svardstav.
>>
File: 1374732719084.jpg-(93 KB, 1200x1666, 060.jpg)
93 KB
93 KB JPG
>>26225826
MY LEGEND DATES BACK TO THE 12TH CENTURY!
>>
>>26225778
That's a falx by the way. Interestingly, the edge is on the inside of the curve
>>
File: 1374732747621.jpg-(228 KB, 926x912, 886977169625.jpg)
228 KB
228 KB JPG
>>26225891
>Not a Flamberge
>>
>>26225928
My sword is on a stick, your argument is invalid.
>>
>>26225910
Voiced by same person that did DeWitt & Joel.
ﺧ益ﺨ
>>
File: 1374732822219.jpg-(73 KB, 900x620, 1370311770193.jpg)
73 KB
73 KB JPG
>>26225928
Edgar Winter, what the fuck are you doing.
You are not a weapon.
>>
>>26225949
polearm + sord = unbeatable
>>
File: 1374733030597.jpg-(39 KB, 840x840, 1364421949640.jpg)
39 KB
39 KB JPG
>>26225916
That's half why I posted it.
I'd still rather have macebat. It's just so stylish.
>>
Since we're on the topic of anime...
Has /tg/ ever had Legend of The Galactic Heroes threads?

That would be an interesting setting
>>
>>26226093
But Battletech already covers space politics.
>>
>>26226093
>Has /tg/ ever had Legend of The Galactic Heroes threads?
Yep.
/tg/ loves LoGH.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fPeLIXWLaiw
>>
File: 1374733210029.jpg-(17 KB, 400x256, 1302742516499.jpg)
17 KB
17 KB JPG
>>26226049
If the style you are going for is "modern barbarian", and I'm ok with this.
>>
>>26226127
Think more Tyler Durden.
>>
>>26226093
I have actually written and run several short campaigns of my TotallyNotLegendsofGalacticHeroes RPG but IT WILL NEVER BE READY
>>
File: 1374734479425.jpg-(16 KB, 400x533, 1304473643165.jpg)
16 KB
16 KB JPG
>>26226540
Are you using Travaller by chance? 'cause you should totally if you haven't decided on a system.
>>
>>26223228
People... Like... BLACKSTAR?!

HOW?! (if this is sarcasm my apologies. I've watched the entire series and read some of the manga but haven't touched the fanbase)
>>
File: 1374734707842.jpg-(60 KB, 320x681, 40-fortitude.jpg)
60 KB
60 KB JPG
>>26226127
It also works for the 14th century.
>>
File: 1374734765849.jpg-(216 KB, 1200x1501, 093.jpg)
216 KB
216 KB JPG
>>26226617
Did you read the 3rd Mifune fight by chance? It's more or less the point where he went from Naruto-knockoff to, well having character.
>>
File: 1374734844521.png-(299 KB, 704x400, Tsubaki.png)
299 KB
299 KB PNG
>>26226617
Short answer?
He's amusing. And far less annoying in the manga, as he starts developing a real character other than just being a shallow spoof of a certain spiky-haired jumpsuit-wearer.
Plus, Black*Star screentime means Best Weapon screentime.
>>
>>26225778
Aw sweet, which album/song?

Sage for off-topic
>>
>>26226738
Relayer, but now I'm on to Close to the Edge.
The entire album, not just the songs.
>>
File: 1374734989006.png-(569 KB, 853x480, so_happy.png)
569 KB
569 KB PNG
>>26226715
That's not how you spell 'Spirit'. Tsubaki is fine too.
>>
>>26226673
I must say I have not read that. But if it's like in the anime where he just goes "IM CHOOZE OWN SPECSHUL PATH!!!1!" then I don't think my opinion would change much.
>>
File: 1374735118828.jpg-(74 KB, 269x694, Tsubaki (male).jpg)
74 KB
74 KB JPG
>>26226767
Tsubaki is so fine that she remains fine even when she's a he.
>>
>>26226757
Nice. Best way to listen to prog.
>>
>>26226834
>Only proper way to listen to prog.
ftfy
>>
>>26226673
Mifune is my favorite. He's the only guy who has a 'strong soul' marking him unique among the cast and he wields a shit-ton of katanas.

Kills bad guys and doesn't afraid of anything.
>>
>>26226823
I would let him fuck my ass. No homo.
>>
File: 1374735408490.jpg-(178 KB, 800x1164, soul-eater-1857235.jpg)
178 KB
178 KB JPG
>>26226819
In hopes you go back to reading, look at this.
>>
File: 1374735455762.jpg-(126 KB, 800x1182, soul-eater-1241012.jpg)
126 KB
126 KB JPG
>>26226823
But who doesn't?
>>
Okay question for you guys who've been keeping up.

Is Crona 100% confirmed dead? Because I honestly don't think I can deal with that. It's just so... unfair. I'm used to horrible undeserved deaths in my animu, but I think this is a new bar to be surpassed in terms of sheer "shit's not fair fuck".
>>
>>26226850
Shit son, if it's something like The Yes Album, with more conventional songs, listening to them as singles is okay.
Or if it's full-pretentious like Tales, taking a break is fine.
Really I'd suggesting listening to them all as full albums at least once, but it's really up to you.
Although I will say that Relayer is kind of obviously supposed to be taken as a whole.
>>
>>26226933
Oh... So he actually learns for once... Oh wow.

I... Don't know how I feel about this. For months now he's been my number one most hated character in any work of fiction but now...

I must go and read. Thank you friend.
>>
File: 1374735734527.gif-(999 KB, 500x268, 1369429985842.gif)
999 KB
999 KB GIF
>>26226964
"That is not dead which can eternal lie. And with strange aeons even death may die."

Don't read this if you aren't up to chapter 111 yet! Crona is gonna become the next kishin.
>>
File: 1374735799621.png-(177 KB, 600x378, 1369021867660.png)
177 KB
177 KB PNG
>>26227048
Glad to be of service!
>>
>>26227055
Is Crona male or female?
>>
>>26227105
Yes.
>>
File: 1374735905902.jpg-(32 KB, 700x550, 1374622977616.jpg)
32 KB
32 KB JPG
>>26227105
Yes.
>>
>>26226981
Off topic, but has anyone here tried discussing prog on /mu/? I've heard nothing but bad things about pretension from that board, and I know In the Court of the Crimson King is supposedly one of their top albums so I'd think it would be right up their alley. But whenever I go there, it seems like nothing but metal and indie pseudo-pop.

Plus, the general hatred of "dadrock" I've seen all over this website.
>>
File: 1374736007377.png-(168 KB, 441x700, 1358120753743.png)
168 KB
168 KB PNG
>>26227105
Also, doesn't matter.
>>
>>26227134
>"dadrock"
Okay, I'm not much of a music guy, could you explain what the fuck that's supposed to mean? Is it just an obnoxious asshole way of saying "Anything from before I was born"?
>>
File: 1374736143209.jpg-(77 KB, 704x396, 1368478589992.jpg)
77 KB
77 KB JPG
>>26227116
>>26227119
>>26227153
>>
>>26227180
Basically it's just a term for music that's considered good not on its own merits, but because it was praised by a previous generation. Music you only call good because your parents called it good, not because you actually thought it was good initially.
>>
>>26227134
Fucked if I know.
I'm kinda sorta exactly the dadrock lover they hate, so I avoid /mu/ like the plague, and continue to enjoy the music I like.
I remember the one time I was over there that I didn't regret, I explained how Stairway to Heaven was trying to equate Tolkienesque fantasy and rock.
>>
Please tell me /tg/ is making a Soul Eater homebrew
>>
>>26227195

Autism-chan is really making the derpiest face in that still.
>>
File: 1374736314457.png-(142 KB, 248x510, 1354322539380.png)
142 KB
142 KB PNG
>>26227214
Not in this thread at least. I'd like that though. Probbaly should have mentioned that in the OP.
>>
>>26227209
So it's basically "This music is old and used to be popular, you like it, therefore you cannot possibly like it on it's own merits and I shall look down upon you because I am an arrogant douche"?
>>
>>26227240
So would I. Pity I'm busy. That and I still haven't caught up on the manga.
>>
File: 1374736453643.jpg-(163 KB, 640x480, Death_the_Kid_by_Pilikita.jpg)
163 KB
163 KB JPG
>>26227212
Really? Do you remember what your argument was?

If you don't mind and you remember, could you share?
>>
>>26227271

Not that guy but /mu/ is a pretty shitty board.
>>
>>26227240
Kinda questioning how this is /tg/ related then.
>>
>>26227271
Basically. Welcome to the /mu/ mindset.
>>
>>26227299

Inspiration maybe? It's got a pretty unique setting after all.
>>
>>26227116
>>26227119
>>26227153
So can I imagine Crona has a huge beastly cock under that nun outfit, and I wouldn't be necessarily wrong?
>>
>>26227322
but you wouldn't be Right either
>>
>>26227322
>>26227344
Think of it as Schrodinger's Cock
>>
>>26227344
If huge trap cocks are wrong, I dont want to be right.
>>
File: 1374736676533.jpg-(497 KB, 1000x1000, 1372828797928.jpg)
497 KB
497 KB JPG
>>26227322
It's a mystery.

>>26227299
Setting. And I did mention I forgot to mention that I wanted to start a homebrew in the OP.
>>
>>26227299
>>26227314
A few people were discussing their attempted homebrews and theoretical homebrews earlier in the thread.

On that note, should players be allowed to play witches, and would witch be a class, NPC race that grants spell-like and supernatural abilities, or a racial class like 4E vampirism?
>>
>>26227379
Racial, magic is genetic. The only way to acquire it is like Free did.
>>
>>26227344
wait... wut? hermaphrodite? Because that would be cool.
>>
File: 1374736822644.png-(35 KB, 369x87, whos ready.png)
35 KB
35 KB PNG
whos ready
>>
File: 1374736830353.jpg-(42 KB, 500x650, 430447_394745483874079_19(...).jpg)
42 KB
42 KB JPG
>>26227379
Gotta say racial. You gots it or you don't. Or you steals it ala Free.
>>
>>26227398
No one knows. Last I heard the creator isn't planning on revealing it either.
>>
>>26227398
one could argue chrona is a male/female/futa/hemaphrodite but without word of god everything is both true and false
>>
File: 1374736880102.jpg-(27 KB, 485x430, 1358727403555.jpg)
27 KB
27 KB JPG
>>26227420
NOT ME!
>>
>>26227287
Well it was kinda a central conceit of the album, what with the song right before it being http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WGAKeHQUx-U
and the song after being Misty Mountain Hop. So there was obviously a fantasy inspiration for a large amount of the album. And uh, something about the fanfare before the guitar solo. That's my favorite part, by the way. and the slow transition from acoustic to a more... "conventional" sound, along with the lyrics both hearkening to fairytales and talking of modern things...
Anyways, as I said before, it's late and I'm drunk, although a lot less drunk. I think there's someone who explains it better than I did even when I was sober somewhere on the innanet.
>>
>>26227377
they are not wrong but in this setting they could be there or not. so yea you could imagine him/her having a huge pulsating cock.
>>
File: 1374736912191.jpg-(200 KB, 951x519, 1373610339590.jpg)
200 KB
200 KB JPG
>>26227427
>>26227436
>>
File: 1374736981706.jpg-(185 KB, 800x600, weeaboo.jpg)
185 KB
185 KB JPG
>>26222942
>>
>>26227455
Indeed, it can be what you want it to be. ~IMAGINAATION~
>>
File: 1374737007465.jpg-(365 KB, 800x1000, Smugbitch.jpg)
365 KB
365 KB JPG
>>26227441
Sssssssh, sssssssh. Embrace the pain.

>>26227322
>>
>>26227485
commander keen.jpg
>>
>>26227442
Thank you anon! I hope you will share one day when you're not quite so tipsy.

>>26227397
>>26227421
Right then. How much power should it confer? Should it be a PC race, need level adjustment? How would stealing magic function to make it not OP?
>>
>>26227508

I think a supernatural ghosts n shit race like that could be pretty cool. I like ghost stories and stuff (I don't believe them but find them interesting), which is one of the reasons I liked Geist: The Sin Eaters so much.

Speaking of which, Geist has some similarities to this show.
>>
File: 1374737199444.gif-(2.56 MB, 160x120, th_auavt3.gif)
2.56 MB
2.56 MB GIF
>>
>>26227508
well the only example was by taking the eye of a witch, so I guess having the organ of a witch gives you magical properties.
>>
>>26227494
Ah, left the link out.

http://imgur.com/sfqUbta

NSFW
>>
>>26227508
Aquiring it at least would require an unique artifact level magical 'thingy' determined by the GM. Be it body parts or crystal implants or whatevs.
>>
>>26227508
Well, if you have people roleplaying its not that much of an issue, should probably have a level-adjustment anyway. probably +1, because of social stigmas, probably a non-PC race unless they take.
>>
File: 1374737307702.png-(40 KB, 221x219, Uhummm.png)
40 KB
40 KB PNG
>>26227536
L-lewd
>>
>>26227536
Well...that is...excuse me for a moment.
>>
File: 1374737419054.png-(175 KB, 651x498, 1354325792715.png)
175 KB
175 KB PNG
>>26227536
DAMNIT BLACKHEART! I KNEW YOU WERE GONNA POST THAT! It's fine, whatevs, I just don't want this thread deleted too soon.
>>
cool a soul eater thread

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K1IWuW8KKJs
>>
>>26227572
I'm sorry, but your bunk is in for maintenance.
>>26227589
He didn't actually post it so I think its safe.
>>
File: 1374737526511.png-(123 KB, 362x224, 1363369508396.png)
123 KB
123 KB PNG
>>26227589
Hence why I linked to it like a good, law abiding citizen of a virtuous and moral blue board! Haw haw!
>>
>>26227621
I don't understand the point of blue-boards when hyper lewd advertisements and banners are allowed throughout the site. Seriously, it's not like 4chan is exactly something you'd want to be browsing at work anyway.
>>
>>26227688
That's something I was thinking about since you should be on 4chan in a work environment, and you must be 18 to use.
>>
File: 1374738021253.jpg-(189 KB, 960x720, 184969_558713254143967_19(...).jpg)
189 KB
189 KB JPG
Alright, serious-ish homebrew mode.

Important mechanics for a SE homebrew:
1. Insanity/Madness
2. Witches
3. Combat, hopefully awesome and/or fluid
4. Soul Resonance
5a. Weapons
5b. Miesters
>>
I very much enjoy Soul Eater. I'll e ven admit it has a lot of potential as a homebrew. Problem is, it would be a clusterfuck and a half trying to shoehorn it into even the most flexible systems.

That said, I'd love to play a competitive campaign. Start at the academy, first player to make a death scythe wins. Shinanegans ensue. Throw in some recurring bad guys and a few psuedo-plots, and you have a great game. Even the GM gets to have fun thinking up new fairytale/gothic baddies to introduce.
>>
File: 1374738085154.png-(234 KB, 853x480, 1368572536861.png)
234 KB
234 KB PNG
>>26227688
From what I understand the issue is that porn draws interest, interest draws people, people might not be interested in anything else the board have and this is bad. Another is shitposting, because clearly, you cant shitpost without porn.

But whatever, I dont really care eitherway, and this is a /q/ sort of question.
>>
>>26227836
huh, didn't think of that.
>>26227809
Lets get started
>>
>>26227809
Well first we have to note that "all people have madness inside them", so that would likely have to be something that increases and decreases with events.
>>
Obligatory
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kzPlHgjnpSk
>>
>>26227809
Due to the over the top nature of combat in the series, I think something similar to wushu would work well. The more in depth you describe your actions, the better chance you have of pulling it off.
>>
File: 1374738492975.jpg-(64 KB, 392x434, 1371357441476.jpg)
64 KB
64 KB JPG
>>26227857
I'm thinking D6 heavy with D100 for stuff like madness/sanity.

>>26227895
Yes. But how much before they crack? Can they tap it for energy?

>>26227943
Hmmm, mite b cool. A bit like WoD-ish?
>>
>>26227809
1. There are many systems for this, but we might need to think of something new because madness is usually a negative thing, rather than a trade off for power that (usually) doesn't make you any less combat effective (and probably makes you moreso)

2. So far we have that they should be a race and that their power should be able to be stolen, but only with high level magic. Player witches have not yet been figured out, but >>26227556
had some ideas so we can start from there.

3. No ideas yet, except those that tie into weapon/meister.

4. >>26225886
Had a system but said it was better in theory than in practice, but maybe we could work something out with it since it's a cool premise.

5(ab). The main problem here is control. Obviously players should control a meister, but whether the weapons are players, DMPCs, or secondary player-controlled characters is still up for debate.
>>
>>26227921
YOU GAVE ME A SCRIPT WITH BONERS IN IT!
>>
>>26227943
If we use a mat, there should be a lot of focus on movement and positioning
>>26227966
That's the question. Maybe if we do a straight percentage, and reaching 100% makes you lose control?
>>
>>26227966
well, for how much, we could run through the series and try and quantify their insanity.
As for d6 heavy I like as d6 is the most common
>>
>>26225507
This, seriously. The blonde girl & the scythe guy were okay. The other two pairs were unbearable.
>>
>>26227809
Should Soul Resonance be something decided once, something that can be affected in scenes, something you roll with each attack? There are a lot of ways to interpret it.
>>
>>26228040
I think it should be an advanced combat maneuver that takes up some kind of points, and you need to succeed at doing, but should be rather potent
>>
>>26228009
>>26225507
Then why are you in a soul eater thread???
>>
>>26228009
What've you got against symmetry anon?

In all seriousness though, Death the Kid had some annoying qualities but he was a pretty solid and idealistic character (at least later on). Plus, considering how he's the son of the primal incarnation of Death I'd sorta be disappointed if he didn't seem alien and borderline mentally ill from a human perspective.
>>
File: 1374738940733.jpg-(86 KB, 500x628, 1374297267661.jpg)
86 KB
86 KB JPG
>>26228092
>>
File: 1374738941513.jpg-(33 KB, 1024x576, The Syms.jpg)
33 KB
33 KB JPG
>>26228107
Pic didn't work
>>
>>26227977
THESE ARE DICK JOKES AREN'T THEY?!
>>
>>26228082
If we look at it like that, those points would likely be spell charges. Used for advanced attacks, healing, etc. But then, what about moves that project your soul wavelength like Black Star Big Wave?
>>
>>26228082
Hmmm, maybe after being 'unlocked' its a battle maneuver-thing. Later stronger pairs can 'maintain' it for longer periods of time.
>>
/tg/: Anime and Manga.
>>
>>26228132
It's probably better that we have it be a number of points you raise with levels, and they allow you to roll a special ability. For example: Spend one point to activate With Hunter. If you roll high enough, the move works.
>>
>>26228160
>4chan: Anime and Manga
>>
>>26228124
>>26228132
hmmm. well moves like the big wave are less taxing than soul resonance
>>26228179
it'd would take more than one point, either that or soul wavelength attack a la Stein and Black Star would cost fractional points.
>>
File: 1374739291087.jpg-(29 KB, 500x525, 1358125778904.jpg)
29 KB
29 KB JPG
>>26227998
San check, roll, higher or lower than target, go insane or tap into maddness improving combat?
>>
>>26228219
Fair enough, I was just using that as an example. We'd need lots of different techniques that require different levels of resonance, and Witch Hunter wouldn't probably be a low level one. But Big Wave doesn't actually use soul resonance, which is why maybe we should divide moves into Weapon and Meister techniques.
>>
>>26228242
lower than, both. plus the different kinds of insanity, like death being the insanity of order or whatever
>>
>>26228160
Usually /tg/ has good taste with that shit, except when it doesn't.
But hey, this place got me to watch The Big O, so that makes up for all the fate/stay night garbage, the Strike Witches bullshit, the girl und pa...
wait.
No it doesn't.
>>
>>26228242
Tapping into madness should have a negative effect that discourages long term or repeated use. Maybe it's boosts your stats for the encounter but weakens you increasingly the more you use it without resetting the counter?
>>
>>26228242
Damn, Stein was done really well. I've suffered through some pretty major mental sickness (hallucinations, extreme paranoia, loss of compassion) myself and he sorta reminds me of myself in some ways. It's... Unsettling to say the least.
>>
>>26228296
go read Drifters, watch Hellsing: Ultimate and Legend of the Galactic Heroes and read Dogs: Bullets and Carnage, might make up for your percieved slight, and I'm sorry you didn't enjoy what we recommended
>>
>>26228310
hmmm. what about the synergy?synch ratio? whatever it was called from Double Cross, that went up when you used your powers, I'd look it up, but my copy is at home.
>>
>>26228296
>>26228375
Just remember to not watch later episodes of Hellsing around anyone you might want to be friends with. That goes double for discussion.
>>
File: 1374739825377.png-(334 KB, 853x480, so_boss.png)
334 KB
334 KB PNG
>>26228326
Stien is a paragon of knowing how to insane in a sane way.

>>26228310
>>26228292
Sanity stat, degrades with more uses of Madness. Madness increases when Sanity drops.

The lower the San, the harder to return from madness?
>>
>>26228436
That could work. But obviously all characters can't start out with the same sanity, so something has to determine it. And is that all it affects?
>>
>>26228375
I think I'm just going to go down a "must see media" list. You have to slog through much less crap.
I mean fuck, I still haven't seen Brazil, or A Clockwork Orange. I just saw Fight Club last month. What the fuck.
>>
File: 1374739923020.jpg-(79 KB, 1280x720, She'll Fucking Destr(...).jpg)
79 KB
79 KB JPG
>>26228428
If they can't appreciate a woman having her head ground down against a wall until there's nothing but an ear and a flap of skin left as payback for killing the guy the one doing the grinding is in love with, they aren't worth being friends with.
>>
>>26228461
I was referring more to the various -philias.

I don't think it's possible to not appreciate late-series Seras
>>
>>26228296
> the big O
Haven't seen it but heard it's batman with mechs, so sounds good.
> fate/stay Night
I know people who love it and people who hate it. I personally enjoyed it and fate/zero.
>strike witches
I haven't seen it, but a friend recommended it so I'll give it a chance.
>girls und pansers
It has cute girls and tanks. What's not to like?

Go read berserk. It's the kinda grimdark stuff /tg/ seems to enjoy.
>>
>>26228436
the double cross thing is <power increase thing> <thing above a certain number? MOAR DICE>
<Have over X at end of session?You retire your dude as he goes insane and uses his awesome powers to kill everyone or is killed by other PCs>
>>
File: 1374740101684.png-(324 KB, 853x480, SCREACH ALPHA.png)
324 KB
324 KB PNG
>>26228457
Slap 'Casablanca' and 'Dark City' on that list and it looks solid. If you haven't watched them already that is.

>>26228455
Starting San/Mad is different for different people.
>>
>>26228497
Yes but what determines it? If we aren't doing a class based system then something else has to. And is it worth investing less ability points in sanity for strength or speed, when a bad roll could leave you ruined?
>>
>>26228457
>a clockwork orange
Be absolutely certain before you watch this. It will be permanently seared into your brained after watching it.
>>
>>26228508
hmm. How many kinds of insanity are we going for? and How are they different?
>>
File: 1374740487972.png-(267 KB, 853x480, CRAZY MAKA.png)
267 KB
267 KB PNG
>>26228491
Hehe! I like. X being variable for different peeps and can decrease/grow/regen?

>>26228508
I was thinking a stat system Call of Cthulhu-ish: get stats and then skills/features.

>>26228530
Singing in the rain doesn't make me cringe any more.
>>
>>26228587
at the end of every session you get a roll to reduce your whatever ratio, you can double the dice you roll, but earn less xp, and/or roll those bastards twice, but get no xp. I only got the book recently so am about 60% on my memory, If I had the book I'd quote shit but I can't, sorry
>>
>>26228587
Maybe we could make sanity a defense stat? Derive it from will, and have enemies roll against it?
>>
>>26228637
I don't think you should draw power from your defense stat. Also, Black Blood, y/n?
>>
>>26228734
Maybe. What if it's an (incredibly unconventional) magic item? Like a (3.5) graft in terms of how it works?
>>
>>26228756
It'd have to be pretty high level considering it's effects. Likely you would have to get all the way to Deathscythe for it to be fair use.
>>
File: 1374741470858.gif-(956 KB, 320x180, 1361068048874.gif)
956 KB
956 KB GIF
>>26228631
"Do you like your character or do you want him stronger?" Also like.

>>26228637
Hmmm, and your mental defenses would decrease with your sanity. Interesting

I just remembered I have work tomorrow. I'll start another thread at the same time tomorrow? Any preferences for the time for the next thread, if this isn't dead by then?
>>
>>26228756
The problem is, only Chrona and Soul iirc have it and it was made by Medusa, then the Lord British Postulate kicks in
>>
>>26228793
the odd way the game works is PLAYERS and THE GM get experience not characters so it may not work
>>
>>26228793
I get home at 2, but I dunno when I'll have time to sit down. I'm super interested in this homebrew though. Really hyped.
>>
>>26228793
hmm. my connection is nonexistant after about 3 tomorrow til about 3 o clock monday so I may not be present unless I go out to the librarium.
>>
>>26228775
Perhaps, but perhaps not. The fact that it can do pretty messed up things to your mind AND take total control over your physical/mental form are pretty big drawbacks. Maybe it should be available relatively early, and simply be a REALLY bad idea until high level?
>>
File: 1374741799284.jpg-(91 KB, 620x719, 545178_433101276705166_17(...).jpg)
91 KB
91 KB JPG
>>26228801
>Lord British Postulate
In then words of the virgin mary, "Come again?"

>>26228816
Well, apply it to the characters. It seems kinda cool. We could always drop it.

>>26228818
What time zone we talking? I'm glad you hyped, 'cause I know I am.

>>26228831
Time zone muther hubard.
>>
>>26228842
Perhaps taking is as a feat or something. You can take extra feats to strengthen it's effects, but doing so puts you at a greater risk.
>>
File: 1374741862018.png-(859 KB, 800x623, Harkonnen II.png)
859 KB
859 KB PNG
>>26228863
>Lord British Postulate
If you stat it, players will try to kill it.
>>
>>26228863
I'm PST (-8 GMT)
>>
>>26228863
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/LordBritishPostulate

Meh, Set a time and I can be there, I'll just grab a coat. 'sides I wasn't doing anything else
>>
File: 1374741978596.jpg-(165 KB, 480x360, The Most Vile Murder of L(...).jpg)
165 KB
165 KB JPG
>>26228881
For some reason 4chan put up the wrong pic.
>>
>>26228816
Maybe players play themselves as meisters, and make up their weapon partners. That way they can stat themselves and the weapons separately, but not have to manage both of them as much? Just a thought.
>>
>>26228904
I can grab my copy of Double Cross tomorrow and try and explain the relevant parts I was referencing
>>
>>26228948
I didn't even know you were, haha.
>>
>>26228962
the players getting xp not characters and the ratio thingy for insanity
>>
>>26228985
It's an interesting idea, but I think it should wait until after I've rested and collected my thoughts. See you on the other side, comrade.
>>
>>26229021
Indeed. Rest well
>>
File: 1374742480371.png-(123 KB, 350x309, later maka.png)
123 KB
123 KB PNG
>>26228881
MKII? Impressive lil vampire.

>>26228884
>>26228895
Lets go with a safe 9pm PST, translating to 00:00 4chan/EST.

Alright. I might be gone, but everybody keep up the good work. See you later.
>>
>>26229046
See you then.
>>
File: 1374748336064.png-(203 KB, 500x337, Free Curious.png)
203 KB
203 KB PNG
>>26225557
>>26225568
>>26225891
>>26227214
>>26227240
>>26227379


If it helps, an old GM of mine made a D20 based ruleset for Soul Eater.
Since it's not for profit because lolpleasedon'tsueme and my copy's fairly old anyway, I played while it was still in beta, about a year ago, and don't know if it's been updated since then, I can't see any harm in letting the cat out of the bag if /tg/ wishes.
>>
>>26230053
Please do. I suppose. Couldn't hurt. I think.
>>
File: 1374749116868.jpg-(680 KB, 1680x1050, Excalibur.jpg)
680 KB
680 KB JPG
>>26230099
Okay, well, enjoy, you crazy kids.
Or don't. Whatever. I'm not your mother. Yet.
http://www.mediafire.com/?iaoud08vtil2uw2
>>
>>26230138
I'd be rather concerned if you were. She's atrocious at using a PC, to suddenly gain competency means she's some weird GMPC
>>
File: 1374752941757.png-(67 KB, 769x982, Crona_s_Fate.png)
67 KB
67 KB PNG
Crona is female. There can be no other answer.
>>
>>26230591
'fraid not. See >>26227536
>>
>>26230138
This looks pretty good.
>>
>>26230654
>>26230591
Get on my level: http://exhentai.org/g/109147/6cb20fd5cd/
Izumi is heavy on the censor but she's done two doujins where Chrona is a futa.
>>
>>26224952
The latest chapter outright says at the end that the next one is the final
>>
>>26230968
gladly.
>>
A not game-related question, coming through.

Is anime good up to some point from which I can continue on reading the manga or is it just full of non-canon filler like Fullmetal Alchemist original series?

It was pretty cool filler, but manga is easily superior
>>
>>26231118
I believe that's mentioned up-thread anon
>>
>>26228107
I agree with that logic regarding Kid alone, but the problem is that ol' Lord Death isn't yet more alien and insane-seeming.

Unless that's different in the manga, I've only seen the anime. Reading the manga is something I've been meaning to do forever.
>>
To keep this more /tg/ related, I inadvertently once made a character with a super power similar to Medusa's, speed-related arrows and all. Still, I'm pretty sure my guy can take her, because if you have a Stand, you usually tend to be a very tactical fighter.
>>
>>26230968
your gallery is pining for the fjords anon
>>
>>26231118
The first half follows the manga and is the best, the second half was made up by the show writers for the most part and is still worth watching if you really liked the first half. So yeah, it's kinda like the first FMA, except I don't think that had such a hard cut-off point between full-cannon and then entirely off the rails.

That said, I keep hoping and hoping that Soul Eater gets the equivalent of FMA Brotherhood. It's my number one anime wish.
>>
>>26231177
how'd you manage that. Also the thread is /tg/ related, all pnp homebrews are.
>>
>>26231129
But there are probably spoilers up there ;_;
>>
>>26230591
I don't know about no other answer, but there is certainly no other personal preference.
>>
>>26231185
Oh, I see. Thank you.

Time to get downloading, then.
>>
>>26231200
its around the arachnaphobia arc/the battle with mosquito
yeah. I'd reccommend just reading it all.
>>
>>26231186

He could lay down arrows on flat surfaces that things would stick to and move along like a track. Think a different version of the speed boosters from Mario Kart. He used this to tangle up enemies, zone them, launch people and objects at things, and more.
>>
>>26231253
nice. I just love how versatile they are.
>>
>>26231118
Watch up to the Battle for Brew.
It stays fairly on the rails until then.
>>
>>26231137

It's sort of...Death forces himself to be human. And he's had a lot of experience with it.

When he stops bothering? It gets scary. Fast.
>>
File: 1374763621649.jpg-(151 KB, 768x671, 1369558734910.jpg)
151 KB
151 KB JPG
I'm off. See you round folks
>>
File: 1374763879949.jpg-(64 KB, 675x720, maka.jpg)
64 KB
64 KB JPG
>>26225716
I think I saved one of the best ones...
>>
>>26231218

Warning: The ending is rather disapointing, though.
>>
>>26231934
Are you talking about how he used to look scarier, or more serious differences?

Also I really thought it was neat how he intentionally changed his appearance to not scare people. I love the idea of not evil or straight-up good types who just happen to look evil and scary. If my superhero fantasies ever came true, I'd be the freaky wraith made of shifting elemental darkness who gets kittens out of trees and that sort of thing. And no angsty stuff either.
>>
>>26231218
Yeah, what >>26232011 said. The last few episodes range from mediocre to good, with the final episode itself being a steaming pile of garbage.
You'll watch it anyway, we're just pre-warning you.
>>
>>26232030

The more serious stuff is implied. Sadly, there's simply not a lot around on Death.

But, watch not just the way he looks, but how he acts when the mask comes off. There's a big change. Not enough to confirm there's major personality differences, but enough to get the thought going.
>>
File: 1374764691452.jpg-(15 KB, 400x300, Lord Death.jpg)
15 KB
15 KB JPG
>>26232030
Death's an eldritch abomination who, upon defeating one of Death's rebellious subjects, drained him of his blood, tore off his skin, trapped his flayed bloodless body within a bag made of HIS OWN SKIN, and then removed Death's own soul to pin this thing in place.
And the moment the guy revives, Death tries to kill him for good, implying he could've done it anytime before if he hadn't wanted so dramatic a torture.
Lord Death is fucking horrifying when he's not trying to not be.
Not to mention his ongoing attempted genocide of the Witch race because they don't fit in with his order.
>>
>>26232110
Heroes who put the law down HARD on evil are the best kinds.

I agree about him being overly harsh toward witches though. Killing them because they're evil, fine. Because they're witches, not so much. Destroy all evil, but keep it to evil, not associated aspects.
>>
>>26232110
Well I have to read this now.
>>
This looks really gay and lame.

Also why is the main character an effete, skinny-limbed bitch?
>>
>>26232257
>skinny-limbed
Pfft. You haven't seen her fat ankles.
>>
>>26232269
No, the mallgoth faggot with stripey hair.
>>
>>26232257

Back in my day, trolling meant something.

Also, second on the fat ankles.
>>
>>26232280

Kidd? He's a secondary protagonist, not primary.
>>
>>26232288
To be fair, before I knew anything about Soul Eater, I saw some images and just assumed Kid was the primary protagonist.

Wasn't until just recently when I started watching it that I realized that Maka and Soul were the main characters.
>>
>>26232398

Yeah, I can totally see that happening.
>>
ump
>>
>>26232169
He does it because he is the madness of order, where the Kishin is the madness of fear
>>
Man I came up with so many ideas today, it's a miracle I had time to get work done. First of all I came up with some rough ideas for chargen, including two sets of combat stats. I also came up with some ideas of how we could do two character combat. It seems that this will probably have to be a combat centered game, since roleplaying two people AND having fun and dramatic combat is hard.
>>
>>26239977
But isn't it the goal of Meisters to collect the souls of 99 Kishin Eggs, and a Witch? Sounds pretty combat intensive to me.
>>
>>26240057
Which brings me to that. Obviously the only solution to Kishin Eggs is to make them EXP. 5 to a level. And a Witch Soul to reach cap. That means a level cap of 20. We can have that be a shared meter for teams, or we can have weapons do that while Meisters do normal EXP
>>
>>26240137
From the source its a very classless affair, mainly seeking improvement with no path, so however we deterine experience/increases in power every option is most likely going to be available to everyone
>>
File: 1374798242227.png-(575 KB, 853x480, WAAAAAAA.png)
575 KB
575 KB PNG
I'm back early and I'm glad to see the thread is still here.

>>26230053
>>26230138

Hmmmm. HHHMMMMMMM. I dunno about d20 based, but there is a lot of love in this. I'm probbly gonna be assecing this for a while. Thanks for contributan!

>>26232110
That's our Lord Death! Protector of Humanity! I hope Kid does a good job when he takes over.

>>26232169
Kishin eggs is a term only used in the anime. Lord Death could deem anyone 'unworty of living' and put a bounty on their head to be hunter down buy legally trained assassins. STILL THE BEST

More Homebrewing?
>>
File: 1374798266561.jpg-(30 KB, 612x337, The Soul Eater World AU.jpg)
30 KB
30 KB JPG
Welcome to Soul Eater AU the MMO.

Seriously...

Illuminati = Witches, Power over everything else, making deals with devils and incriminating photo's of angels. Do or get Done.

Templar = DWMA. Everything must be kept in order, yes we can work together but step out of line and your dead.

Dragon = Medusa/Crona/Kishin. Send the world in Chaos, be the one to pick up the pieces and then throw them in the air again.
>>
>>26240191
I'm fine with that. The only "class" thing I was thinking is weapon type. I was thinking melee weapons, range weapons, and magic. That would allow for a balanced team aesthetic.
>>
>>26240221
of course, although, a couple hours from now I gotta jump for a while, I'll probably be back after
>>
>>26239977
For stats I was thinking normal stuff for the most part. Strength, Agility, Constitution, Intelligence, and finally Sanity and Wavelength. I had some pretty cool ideas of how to work wavelength in.
>>
File: 1374799046088.png-(460 KB, 853x480, siiiiiip.png)
460 KB
460 KB PNG
>>26239977
This is true. But roleplaying is a vital component that can surround the combat without hindering. Spill the bean meng, rough ideas can be hammered into sharp pointed objects.

>>26240291
Cool cool, I'm basicaly just reading >>26230138 While waiting for moar peeps. Did say 9pm PST so I'm assuming more people will come at that time.
>>
>>26240453
Stats would be Str/Con/Agi/Int/San(ity)/Wav(elength

They would be printed twice, once for Meister and once for Weapon. The difference comes into play with combat stats. Meisters would have defenses, Toughness, Sanity, Dodge, and Parry. Then they would use Str and Agi for attacks, Wav for abilities. Weapons would have combat stats too, but they'd be Sharpness for damage, and Durability to take the pain from being used to block attacks. Dodging an attack would mean you have to save against fatigue, and failing the save gives you fatigue counters. The more you get, the worse you are in the fight, meaning you don't want to drag them out if you can avoid it. If you parry it with your weapon, it has to save, which means it's even riskier to keep fights going long. The thing is, it only makes sense that weapons can switch back and forth between forms in battle, but doing so allows for a lot of nuance. We can make feats for being able to partially transform, being able to transform quickly, and stuff like that. I should actually probably organize this into seperate posts, but I don't know how to exactly.
>>
>>26240606
Dodge: Derived from agility. When a range attack is made against you, it targets your dodge defense. Taking the hit does damage and applies normal effects. Dodging attacks allows you to move into a space outside the area of effect, but will force you to save against fatigue. Failing the save will increase your fatigue by one point, and upon accumulating points your defenses may suffer, as well as your damage, speed, and ability to match wavelengths.
>>
>>26240606
I remember this analogy happened in the anime, and I think the manga, but isn't using a weapo like using an amp for your wavelength?
>>
>>26240678
Parry: Derived from weapon Durability. When a physical attack is made against you, it targets your Parry defense. Taking the hit does damage and applies normal effects. Parrying the attack avoids damage, but forces your weapon partner to save against durability damage. If the save fails, your weapon partner accumulates fatigue. Too much fatigue will lower your weapon's sharpness, and may even force him out of his/her transformed state. At this point, you will be forced to rely on your own physical ability, or the generosity of your squadmates with their weapons, and your own ability to match wavelengths with an unfamiliar weapon.
>>
alright, who would win

Whatever that demons name is in Soul Eater or Yawgmoth?
>>
>>26240746
Yes, but I'm trying to make weapons a more integral part of the game.
>>
>>26240777
well, each weapon amplifies the meister differently and to different degrees, I'm just wondering should combat damage be derived from a combination of Wav and Str? or just Str?
>>
>>26225287
Soul Eater has awful noses, there's nothing to be done about them.
>>
>>26240798
I was thinking that the attack roll is from the meister, and the damage comes from the weapon. We can have abilities be derived from Wav.
>>
File: 1374800636892.png-(685 KB, 853x480, those who cant see souls.png)
685 KB
685 KB PNG
>>26240606
Yes! I like how you incorporated Weapons as being more than Weapon form.

>>26240678
Hurm. Degrading combat effectiveness. Making tough scary fights scarier as they get longer.

>>26240746
In both they did.

>>26240765
Oh~ More making the Weapon work.

>>26240768
It's 'Ashura' by the way. And I'd have to say Yawgmoth; ol' Yawgy wasn't beaten by 3 high schoolers with magic weapons., also, wizards just rule.

>>26240810
It can't be helped.
>>
>>26240828
I can see that working, but it makes the problem of needing an even numbered group of people half of which are willing to weapons for other PC's, or have Players manage two-characters simultaneously
>>
>>26240846
welcome back I suppose, I don't know if I said that yet.
>>
>>26240870
That's the inherent problem with this subject. Somebody has to sit there and do nothing but roll for someone else's decisions. My idea? Just have the player roll for both, and leave it up to the group to decide who roleplays the weapon. It's a homebrew, it's allowed to be a little gritty. It adds character.
>>
>>26240896
Yeah that works.
>>
>>26240226

>tfw ded game
>>
>>26240768
let's see

>someone who was beaten by a bunch of sharply dressed teenagers. Could also spread madness

or

>Ruler of an entire plain of existence
>a literal God
>leads an army of Eldrich horrors
>his mere presence kills millions
>had to be killed by the 5000 years planning of the most powerful wizard of all time whom needed to sacrifice himself to kill him

looks like a tossup to me
>>
>>26240765
Strength: Determines melee attack success, and athletics rolls.

Agility: Determines ranged attack success, Dodge defense, and speed.

Constitution: Determines HP, Fortitude defense, and fatigue save bonus.

Intelligence: Determines mental rolls such as history, medical, magic, etc.

Sanity: Determines sanity defense, and bonus to sanity saves.

Wavelength: 1) Increases the odds of you resonating with a weapon. Meaning a higher stat affords you a wider arsenal to draw from. 2) Increases the damage done by resonation abilities such as Witch Hunter, and Death Cannon.
>>
>>26240975
I can also see Yawgmoth being resistant to madness via phyresis and similar technologies, whereas I can't think of anything that would stop Ashura's flesh from being Compleated. That being said, if he was made Compleat he'd probably be at least a Praetor
>>
>>26240768
they'd probably become bros
>>
File: 1374801503763.jpg-(8 KB, 120x68, is dis nigga serious.jpg)
8 KB
8 KB JPG
>>26225507
>WHACKY OCD BADASS
DTK doesn't have OCD, he has OCPD.

>>26225507
>LE BEING NINJA BUT NOT BEING SNEAKY XDD
You DO know that Black Star is supposed to be a parody of Naruto, right?
>>
>>26241030
I have one problem, but its not something I know how to fix, brute strength doesn't help as much as dexterity/coordinatinon when trying to hit in close combat
>>
>>26231992
>>26225716
>>26225687
Link?
>>
>>26241107
I agree. We could make melee attacks derive from Agility as well, but that means nobody would bother putting points into Strength.
>>
File: 1374801725511.png-(304 KB, 675x720, 1374715782533.png)
304 KB
304 KB PNG
>>26241115
http://suptg.thisisnotatrueending.com/archive/26215956/
You're welcome.
>>
>>26241121
Still takes strength to put the force behind the hit. I see WAV as an amplifier of what you have, not what you work off. I may be contradicting myself here though
>>
File: 1374801773520.gif-(1.54 MB, 500x281, DTK overreacts.gif)
1.54 MB
1.54 MB GIF
>>26226964
Whoa! Spoiler that shit.
>>
>>26241163
But if we derive damage from Strength, then the weapon becomes a hunk of metal with no personality. Maybe we just don't use strength? And making damage/effect derive from Wav means people will build around a high Wav score, and we want to encourage diversity.
>>
>>26241163
What if there are classes/playstyles besides Meister that can use strength? Like legendary warriors (Mifune) and perhaps non-evil werewolves?
>>
>>26241157
Sweet, thanks.
>>
>>26241209
Let's worry about figuring out the vanilla game before we get to stuff like that. But I like where you're going with this, it could work.
>>
File: 1374802028127.jpg-(174 KB, 720x480, 1371360650245.jpg)
174 KB
174 KB JPG
>>26241168
GB2 http://www.mangareader.net/157/soul-eater.html YOU ASYMMETRICAL DUNKASS!
>>
>>26241209
I didn't see Free as evil, Lawful perhaps, as he's honoring his debts. Also, it would be kickass to play as Mifune, but lord british postulate and all that, that's why I'm conflicted on Black Blood
>>
Was it ever confirmed that Excalibur is a Warlord?
>>
>>26241291
I think so, yes.
>>
>>26241251
I'm a firm believer that Black Blood shouldn't be a 'core' thing. Its kinda the grease in SE plot so explaining why Medusa this, Maka/Soul that seems silly. BUT some GMs would probbly want to know how to incorporate it, say if they interceting with the main plot or doing alt universe shenanigans. Core feature, no. GM tingymagigger, fine.
>>
>>26241291
Yeah.

Excalibur is Rage while Ebon, Asura and Death are Knowledge, Terror and Order respectively.
>>
>>26241251
I don't really see him as evil either, and I should have phrased that differently. I mean, non-villainous werewolves.

Speaking of which, do we know of any besides Free? Because if he's any representation of the race as a whole, then werewolves could function sort of as a LN psuedo-paladin class.
>>
>>26241325
I say we make it a feat that ranks. You have to have low sanity to take it, and each rank increases it's effectiveness.
>>
File: 1374802380838.gif-(1.79 MB, 400x225, 1372721171052.gif)
1.79 MB
1.79 MB GIF
>>26241291
Implied like 2 times, but never stated.
>>
>>26240941
actually the game goet a 400% increase in players when it went F2P, if it keeps churning out patches, new content, and new ideas the game can get better.
>>
>>26241337
I think he might be the only one, as I can't remember any others being mentioned, but, they call him a werewolf so....

>>26241325
If its there at all, so is Medusa, Soul and co.
Which means PC's are, eventually, going to try and kill them
>>
File: 1374802487957.png-(471 KB, 675x720, 1374712387463.png)
471 KB
471 KB PNG
>>26231992
this is the best.

undisputed

>YOUR FACE WHEN ASHURA WINS DA SUPERB OWL
>>
>>26241360
>>26241337
Free is the last werewolf because Death exterminated them all like he's trying to do with the witches.

And the only reason he's still alive is because he's immortal.
>>
>>26241360
Not if we place the story after they died.
>>
File: 1374802610529.png-(315 KB, 700x483, 1354319497678.png)
315 KB
315 KB PNG
>>26241350
>>26241360
Freakin Black Blood making my fun hard.

>>26241386
We can't do that. We have to allow for multiple different scenarios.
>>
>>26241407
Fair enough. I'm taking that make pic by the way. I need it for my wall.
>>
>>26241374
still gives me a boner.
>>
File: 1374802985835.gif-(997 KB, 500x281, 1363163749043.gif)
997 KB
997 KB GIF
>>26241477
It better.

>>26241456
Glad to be of assistance.
>>
>>26241477
>>26241456
gentelmen, contain yourselves until class.
>>
>>26241516
Sensei, if Maka wasn't so kawai none of this would be a problem. I demand she wear a bag for the remainder of the semester, lest our studies be interrupted.
>>
File: 1374803202903.jpg-(2.37 MB, 2994x3625, 1374440340351.jpg)
2.37 MB
2.37 MB JPG
>>26241516
It can't be helped. Maka is just that attractive.

>>26241545
FOOL. You can't hide beauty of that magnitude.
>>
>>26241573
>You can't hide beauty of that magnitude.

is David Bowie here?
>>
>>26241030
Back to the subject at hand, does anyone have ideas for leveling? I had some potential ideas, and I'm trying to hammer out a way to do weapon abilities. Dual weilding, multiple forms, partial transformation, it's all stuff we need to work out. Also, we need rules governing the way weapons are created. We can't just let people decide that a wooden spoon has a sharpness of 20, when a scythe has a sharpness of 12.
>>
>>26241545
Not happening boyo
>>26241636
I would assume its got to do with devouring souls, also, how do we deal with people eating human souls and becoming Kishin eggs? Can the recover like Chrona? It kind of seemed like a once off with Chrona
>>
>>26241679
Like I said earlier, let's work on the vanilla game first. I was thinking meisters could get experience, and weapons could use Kishin Eggs to level. 5 eggs to a new ability, meaning a max of 20. And we need to decide things like dual weapon weilding from creation. Maybe a point buy system?
>>
>>26241679
In the manga at least, Crona's 'stash' was confiscated by Lord Death.
>>
>>26241679
Chrona did seem to be a special case, basically having no life.....I think a degree might be sociological thing? That people who live in cities and shit hear that the Reaper says eating souls is bad and anyone who does becomes a Kinshin and is killed....but I'm sure its more than that. Just my two cents.
>>
>>26241730
Could work. What do you mean by "point buy", They mention Dual-Wielding is really difficult as you have to resonate with 2 souls to do it. I think Kid can do it because he's the Son of Death, and Stein can do it because of how good he is with Soul Wavelengths but I don't recall anyone else being able to do it. Wait, were the pots of Fire and Thunder, two different spirits or one?
>>
>>26241915
They were two. And we could do it like that. Make dual wielding a feat that requires a high Wav score?
>>
>>26241984
It would have to, you can't fight with someone you don't resonate with see >>26241248 scene, Black Star can barely lift soul off of the ground.
Also could a weapon fight on their own like soul did in that scene/Justin Law/Chainsaw Golem Man
>>
File: 1374804962508.jpg-(438 KB, 800x522, 1372302263722.jpg)
438 KB
438 KB JPG
>>26242061
STRONK miesters like Stien can, So can weapons like Justin Law and Giriko.
>>
>>26242152
Are we going to allow PC's to be STRONK souls like Mifune?
>>
>>26242171
Possible but it should cost a shitton of XP.
>>
>>26241359
>it went F2P
WHAT WHEN?!
I'd been meaning to check it out, but am poorfag so subscription MMOs are kinda beyond my means.
>>26242171
As far as I know, it's never been explained how one even gets to be one in-setting. Is it something you become, or are you just born that way?
>>
>>26242171
I'd say no. Also, Mifune wasn't even a Miester! Mifune's 99 soul STRONK was kinda what made him unique. Mundanes on the other should be shied away from as they are woefoly weaker than Miesters and Weapons.
>>
>>26242061
We could have solo fighting require the partial transformation feat.

>>26242152
Of course Meisters can fight without weapons, that's the point of physical training. It just limits their capabilities.

>>26242216
We'd need to determine exactly what strong soul means. I don't think we should worry about making non-meister characters yet, but it's good to take notes.
>>
>>26242218
I would assume born
>>
>>26242277
I'm going to go dive into the wikia to find info on Strong Souls
>>
File: 1374806169125.png-(345 KB, 836x894, Mifune's_Soul.png)
345 KB
345 KB PNG
>>26242296
>It is unknown if an individual is born with a Strong Soul or if the specific type of Soul is something that is gained during further life. If it is true that Strong Souls are gained, then the process of obtaining one would more than likely revolve around how an individual lives his or her life. From what has been displayed in the Soul Eater series so far, this particular person will most likely be one of an extremely pure and flawless personality or background. Strictly following The Path Of The Warrior, for example, would serve as a perfect illustration as to what one may gain a Strong Soul from.
Strong Souls normally appear as very large Human Souls. In addition to this, Strong Souls expand even further dependent on their possessor's level of strength and overall power. This can sometimes result in a Soul that looks abnormally and ridiculously large for a Human to have.

Shit.
>>
>>26242513
So, what? A feat? Feats seem to be answering a lot of our problems.
>>
>>26242535
Maybe. Being a strong soul puts you on the level of a meister (or above) without the need for a weapon. I'm just wondering how to handle it mechanically
>>
>>26242513
If we really want to make non-meisters a vanilla class, there's quite a bit of extra work to do. And they would likely be the ones with strong souls.
>>
>>26242598
Its all about options, its why people play pnp's over /v/idya games, the choice. Its why I don't want to restrict people off being Strong Souls
>>
>>26242627
So we can let players take the Strong Soul class. That means we have two classes. And I really don't think we should allow people to play as Witches, at least not yet.
>>
I hope Mifune is alive ;_;
>>26242685
I don't think so either, as if you play as a meister, you'd be (eventually) trying to hunt witches for Shibusen
>>
>>26242711
Witches will basically be Dragons. Big, tough, and not to be fought unless there's no escape.
>>
>>26242806
probably, seeing as they're how you reach end level abilities as a weapon.
>>
>>26242806
Oh. Problem. What are PC's going to do other than hunting Kishin Eggs? From memory all they do is go to class, train, occaisionally play baskeball for R&R, and hunt monsters
>>
>>26242870
Well that's up to the GM. Obviously the goal of the game is to collect souls, but that's like saying the goal of DnD is to gain experience.
>>
>>26242944
I'd say the goal of D&D is to do what you wanna do, be what you wanna be. Character driven and all that.
>>
>>26242870
Goof off with friends, have lessons, train, relax, deal with personal problems both in a combat and non-combat sense, study, investigate the BBEG.

But a lot of it will be combat and murder, as suits it.
>>
>>26243001
Yeah, I figured we were building the game around combat. If we want to build it around roleplay, that's a whole other beast.
>>
>>26243001
>>26243029
Sounds good.
>>
Idea for combat:

-Make melee attack with weapon
-Roll (Agi Mod)d6
-Higher than enemies Parry = Hit
-Roll (Str Mod)d6 + Weapon Sha(rpness)
>>
>>26243029
Most of the crunch will be around combat and the Wavelength and Sanity system.

Out of combat stuff we really don't need as much focus on, though obviously the GM can adjudicate when your wavelength falls out of synch due to having some problems with each other.
>>
>>26243071
We could use an active defense system like GURPS. But y'know modified.
>>
>>26243114
I hate contested rolls. It wastes so much time, and often makes hitting a much harder feat to accomplish.
>>
>>26243143
I suppose.
>>
File: 1374808285055.jpg-(103 KB, 803x850, 1372306526701.jpg)
103 KB
103 KB JPG
>>26242711
For the love of Death, read the manga sometime in the future.

>>26243081
I like this a lot.

I see SE games can have different flavors and directions. Most games will be Death Weapon Miester Academy students and/or faculty. These games could be very 'defeat the deamons, save the day', 'Working for Lord Death isn't all fun and games.', 'THOSE CIVILIANS WEREN'T CULTIST AND WERE UNARMED!' to 'No Johnny, you are the deamons.'

Or on the flip side; PCs as Witches, Monsters and rogue Mietsers/Weapons. Going from running for you life, running a resistance cell, to all out war.
>>
>>26243205
I will dammit, I'm trying.
>>
>>26243178
I like the fatigue system, it means fights are a lot more dramatic. Having contested rolls clashes with it though, because it means if everyone happens to roll well by the end everyone is dead but nobody has landed a hit. And that fight would have taken 2 hours of time.

>>26243205
Yes, I agree. Not ruling too hard on roleplay means more freedom to tell the story. And again, let's not worry about PC Witches yet.
>>
File: 1374808644218.jpg-(380 KB, 1200x1657, chillaxan.jpg)
380 KB
380 KB JPG
>>26243247
How far are you ATM? Remember to spoiler that shenanigans.

>>26243268
Very very true. We need to focus on Weapons and Meisters that we are assuming going to Shibusen.
>>
>>26243349
I have watched the entire anime and mangawise I am up to the 4th chapter as I'm re-reading all of it. I am however aware of some stuff that happens later like everyone going into the book of Eibon, and Mifune dieing(maybe)
>>
>>26243349
Is anyone taking notes? Someone should probably be pasting them to a document for later review.
>>
>>26243439
well if this thread gets archived I'll go over it later and write all the stuff down in a book, but I can't do it right now
>>
File: 1374809002618.png-(390 KB, 853x480, THAT MEDIC IS A SPAH.png)
390 KB
390 KB PNG
>>26243431
'alright. Anime is sufficient.

>>26243439
I'm saving the entire thread at least
>>
So far we have a rough stat system, some possible feats, rough combat.

We still need chargen, leveling, and enemies.
>>
...bump?
>>
>>26243800
We're way into autosage man, bumping does nothing.
>>
>>26243830
What do we do now?
>>
>>26243860
People think about stuff, add meat onto ideas, and make a new thread in a bit.
>>
>>26243860
>>26243887

I'll start at 00:00 like last time. Till then hang on a bit longer please.
>>
>>26243887
>>26243904
Godspeed you glorious bastards
>>
>>26243904
Scratch that. Page 8. Woking on thread. Subject will be Soul Eater again
>>
>>26243904
how long until then?
>>
>>26242218
Well.. B2P, as in you gotta buy the game for like 20/40 dollars. But yeah early this year.
>>
>>26244087
>>26244087
>>26244087
Get in here!
>>
>>26244109
Also changed the Subject to 'Soul Eater Homebrew'


[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post [File Only] Password
Style
[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k] [s4s] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / adv / an / asp / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / out / po / pol / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / x] [rs] [status / q / @] [Settings] [Home]
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

- futaba + yotsuba -
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.