[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k] [cm / hm / y] [3 / adv / an / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / hc / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / po / pol / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / x] [rs] [status / ? / @] [Settings] [Home]
Board:  
Settings   Home
4chan
/tg/ - Traditional Games


File: 1397784714893.png-(1.9 MB, 1280x720, HaremProtagStart2.png)
1.9 MB
1.9 MB PNG
Welcome to Harem Protag Quest. You are John Galt, the sentient protagonist of a harem show. Aside from having to gather and keep your harem, you will have to deal with various other obstacles at the Cassandra College of Witches.
>Mechanics: http://pastebin.com/MuXRzApY
>MC: http://pastebin.com/TdBKC27p
>Other Characters: http://pastebin.com/SCdW9jJi
>Magic system: http://pastebin.com/jKt3dEkR
>Previous threads: http://suptg.thisisnotatrueending.com/archive.html?tags=Harem%20Protag%20Quest
>Twitter: @HaremProtaGuide

>Current Stats:
>Protag Points: 318
>Mana 25/25
>Harem Status 4/5
>Rules are now out of date, I’m going to fix them as soon as I can but for the lowdown: 1, you have to buy new harem slots for 50 protag points apiece. 2, There’s going to be a new level of Harem member between Probationary and Permanent. These won’t immediately affect you, but should bring more dynamics to the quest later. You can of course ask me and I’ll answer to the best of my ability.

You remain paused in the door to your summoning class, staring at the person who will be sitting next to you for the immediate future and one of the few you’ve had issues with, Kaede Sakura. The first time you saw her she nearly immediately wanted to kill you for touching a girl on accident. But then shortly later you preformed a supposedly impossible magic technique on her and some other girls, ripping the mana straight from their bodies. It was to save your collective lives, but that was still probably unpleasant.

Anyway, it’s been a rocky relationship from the start and it isn’t likely to get better immediately. But you do have a couple choices on how to approach this.

>Go sit next to her, say hello, act like nothing’s particularly wrong.
>Go sit next to her, ignore the ever living fuck out of her.
>Nope out of class, you don’t want to deal with this.
>Other.
>>
>>31549460
>Go sit next to her, say hello, apologize for earlier and ask if she'd like to talk about it later
>>
>>31549460
>Go sit next to her, say hello, act apprehensive as if she's about to attempt to murder you.
>>
>>31549460
>Go sit next to her, say hello, act like nothing’s particularly wrong.
Ask if she liked the food.
>>
Yay! Here for the beginning of the best part of the day!

>other

Take a seat, don't say anything, but look at her significantly. We're waiting for her to make a situation out of this.
>>
>sentient protagonist
Oh thank god, I'm so sick of non-sentient protagonists.
>>
Woo welcome back Guide.

>>31549495

This.
>>
>>31549460
>>Nope out of class, you don’t want to deal with this.
>>
>>31549523
Sentient as in, he knows he's in a Harem show and knows what kind of actions are expected of him.
>>
>>31549460
>Go sit next to her, apologies for this morning and ask if she's ok with being partnered with us.
>>
>>31549488
>>31549495
>>31549530

you people are insane.
>>
>>31549460
>>31549487
this
Also Christiane Friedrich: Current Attraction 15 can't be possibly right, it should be in the 20es after last thread
>>
>>31549547
Ah. Well, I think it would be better to say he's a "self-aware protagonist".
>>
>>31549562
and what was your sane suggestion?
>>
>>31549495
Actually, that's a pretty good icebreaker. Support.

>>31549460
Guide you've returned to us! Welcome back.
>>
>>31549495
>>31549555
>>31549530

Guys, you gave this girl PTSD by accident. You can't act flippant about this at all, or she'll strangle us in the middle of class. Take it slow.
>>
>>31549585
>Nope out of class, you don’t want to deal with this.

psycho lesbian can deal with her shit on her own
>>
>>31549495
Perfect.
>>
>>31549578
Guide said in OP that rules are out of date
>>
>>31549495
I don't agree with opening with this, but it seems like it's going to win. As long as we wait for her to make the first move, then I guess we can do this.
>>
>>31549594
Woah woah waoh, let's get one thing straight, she had PTSD before hand and we were involved with activating in only because she sleepwalked into our couch and kissed us before waking up.

You can't lay all of that (or all that much of that) on us.
>>
>>31549649
Also, she tried to put a bullet in our brain the first time we met her.

She is seriously bad juju, not waifu material
>>
Alright, looks like you're manning up and talking to her.

Writing.

Also will attempt to update the pastebins as we go, I know they're kind of out of date.
>>
>>31549668
>>31549649

We will harness the crazy.
>>
>>31549617
It's not rules, it's her current stats. that's probably out of date as well, but it's something that bears mentioning, since she's very close to (what used to be) Permanent status since last thread.

>>31549649

You've never worked with somebody who has mental issues like that? You know why calling somebody crazy is an insult to their reasoning? BECAUSE THEY DON'T FOLLOW LOGICAL REASONING. She's now associating us with reliving her trauma. We're not going to spook her the same way you don't spook a jittery crocodile. they might take your head off if you do.
>>
>>31549598
that would be skipping
we're no a bad student
she's not seriously gonna attack us in the middle of class in front of a teacher
>>
>>31549668
And all this was while she was trying to sexually assault Akeno.
>>
>>31549687
She is a crazy yandere lesbian. If we harness that, it makes our lives measurably worse.
>>
>>31549710
Agreed. But we should at least be polite. Just keep all the thoughts that wish she wasn't here in our head. Preferably away from the magic parts.
>>
>>31549688
True, but given that we live with her I don't really see running away or constantly disengaging as options. Now, depending on how this class goes I might change my mind.
>>
Suggestion for OP Background:

Descendant of King Arthur on our dad's side. Which is why we have the ancestral knowledge of swordsmanship as well as skill with the one area of Magic that can enhance our physical abilities.

The Absurd Magical Sheananigans come from our mother's side, whoever she is.
>>
>>31549762
ARe we descended from arthur's incest baby?
We can also be descended from more historical/mythological figures if need be
>>
>>31549750
I'm not saying we ignore her; far from it. I intend to waifu this bitch and cure her with the D, but the problem here is that you guys are charging ahead balls-first when she's a mentally unstable Yandere and has the trauma fresh in her mind. We should leave her for a day or two to let her calm down, and then start reworking her perception of us. Otherwise she's more likely to pull her guns on us to avoid her trauma again.
>>
>>31549762
Morgana Le Fay, obviously
>>
>>31549750

In fact given that there may be a connection between her and Hasshaku-waifu, running away or disengaging will only make our Eldritch Stalker push us together even more.
>>
>>31549762
I'm generally in favor of "May or may not be decendant/reincarnation of ancient hero who sealed an ancient evil." The effect of that seal? The loss of all magic for all males whose magic was diverted to maintain the seal.
>>
>>31549762
>>31549792

Descent has nothing at all with his skill at all. He's lived a life as a Swordsman, and that skill's bleeding through. maybe his character is, but that's not where he gets his swordsmanship from.
>>
>>31549816
That would explain why males just suddenly gained the ability to use magic one day, somebody tried to break the seal and succeeded partially. And as male mages become more common and gain in strength the seal will weaken further...
>>
>>31549816
The only way that would work is if this is a very clear 'history was lost' world, because having a history of Males using magic would contradict the pastebin that Males have never used magic in recorded history until recently. Maybe it is, but it's never been mentioned before, so I doubt it's the case.
>>
>>31549855
Or just have it happen before recorded history.
>>
>>31549855
It wouldn't be too unreasonable for the knowledge of an ancient evil's existance to be censored, since if it was commonly known, crazies would try and free/summon it
>>
>>31549820

In universe explanation. It's pretty meta how we actually know our swordsmanship.
>>
File: 1397786580860.jpg-(97 KB, 260x400, Teacher2.jpg)
97 KB
97 KB JPG
>>31549460
Swallowing back your mild fear about the girl, you decide that it’s best to deal with her here, in public, where she’s not as likely to kill you. Stepping forward into the classroom, you notice that Kaede glances your way as you enter. Nodding to the old lady of a teacher that you have, you gently approach and set your bag down next to Kaede’s on the table, forming a small but somewhat mutually built barrier between the two of you.

There’s an awkward pause for a few seconds, but you break the silence with something that’s unlikely to get your head bit off.

“Did you enjoy breakfast?” you ask her casually, your voice managing to somehow convey that you’re still aware of the fact that there are major issues between the two of you, but at least in public you’re trying to make a polite face.

“It was…good,” she says slowly, the venom you expected still there but an honest appreciation of your cooking talent making it through.

“Thanks,” you say politely, leaving it there as the teacher begins the class, nothing special but at least you can follow these basics with your current level of skill. The teacher, who seems like a slightly senile grandma type, then tells you to take five minutes between partners to clear up any questions you might have.

Everyone else immediately breaks off into chatting, but you can tell Kaede is not wanting much to do with you. You leave her alone, not wanting to disturb the quiet peace you have.

“How?” it’s one word, short, curt and to the point, but it is a branch, thin and gnarly as it may be, between the two of you.

How do you respond?

>Tell her the truth, including the weird dream.
>Partial truth, you have no clue.
>Just shrug.
>Other.
>>
>>31549912
>Tell her the truth, including the weird dream.
>>
>>31549912
Tell her the truth. Balls to the walls.
>>
>>31549912

>Tell her the truth, including our dream.

She'll only be more suspicious and distrustful of us if we lie to her after magically molesting her and emotionally traumatizing her.

Not to mention that she may know something, as evidenced by her breakdown, and the fact that ???'s affection rose alongside hers during cooking time
>>
>>31549912
>Partial truth, no idea but one of our housemates is helping me look into it.
>>
>>31549912
I woke up and you were sleeping with me. I tried to gently extricate myself but you pulled me back and kissed me.
>>
>>31549946

This.

With a voice of solemn sincerity and concern.
>>
>>31549912
>>Tell her the truth, including the weird dream.
>>
It got quiet real fast.

But looks like you're telling her about your friend from beyond.

Writing.
>>
>>31550029
My Captcha's acting up.
>>
>>31550029
Dunno if its affecting other people, but my computer just stopped displaying captcha, had to post from my phone
>>
>>31550029
Just got here myself.
>>
>>31550029

Sure, works for me.
>>
File: 1397788342651.jpg-(173 KB, 900x491, Maybesomeday.jpg)
173 KB
173 KB JPG
>>31549912
Swallowing, you briefly consider lying to her, but for some reason you decide that that would be a bad idea in the long run and even if she doesn’t believe you, you’ll know your right as she does…whatever is that she will do, seeing as how the two reactions you’ve seen from her have either been “KILL!!!” or “Blind screaming terror.”

“The first day of class…in mysticism, I did something,” you say, “I don’t know what or how, but I saw…something. Something that I couldn’t understand, that terrified me. I’ve been dreaming of it ever since. Last night, it became…better, for me to see and tried to get in a dream bed with me. I…I was still slightly nervous around it so I did. Then I woke up, with you on top of me. After that…well you know what happened.”

Kaede eyes you as you start talking, first obviously wondering where the hell you’re going with this, but then turning more…wondering? Disbelieving?

As you finish you eye her, leaning away slightly in case she decides to try and ventilate you here and now.

But that doesn’t happen, at least not right away. She seems to be…thinking, which actually turns her face to something you can appreciate, instead of hate.

It’s almost time for the teacher to start again when she speaks.

“Meet me after class,” she says, with a voice that’s more like Kaname’s when she asked about your enchantments than with anything you expected from Kaede, “In the quad.”

With that the teacher starts again, finishing up class with what amounts to an overview of what you’d already talked about.

Kaede darts out of class immediately after the teacher dismisses you, leaving you in her dust.

So, now you have a choice.

>Meet Kaede in the quad.
>Uh, nope. (Specify elsewhere)
>Other
>>
>>31550143
>Meet Kaede in the quad.
>>
>>31550143
>>Meet Kaede in the quad
Hrrm
>>
>>31550143
>>Meet Kaede in the quad.
As if there was another option
>>
>>31550143
>Meet her in the Quad
>Head to PE class

I really don't want to disappoint Ms. Black.
>>
>>31550166
I think we have like 2 hours between this class and PT, since last time we napped for an hour then at lunch with Tatsuko for the other hour
>>
>>31550143

Meet in the quad.
>>
Apparently no hesitation to meet her in the quad.

Writing.
>>
>>31550204

[Fear intensifies]
>>
>>31550217
Hey, I wasn't saying anything. You guys are the ones who are paranoid.
>>
>>31550226

[paranoia intensifies]
>>
>>31550226
And for good reason, she wanted us dead just yesterday.
>>
To anyone having problems with captcha not loading - get noscript running, it'll block out java but you'll be able to post again
>>
>>31550226
Guide, I just wanted to let you know that Captcha is completely and utterly broken right now. I literally had to go and buy a 4chan Pass in order to get this through. Keep going if you want, but you're definitely not getting the full range of opinions on your choices right now.
>>
>>31550269
I did the same.
Do we know what's wrong?
>>
>>31550269
Really? It's fine on my end.
>>
>>31550275
Moot broke 4chan again with his floating Captcha, that's what he did. Isn't it obvious?
>>
>>31550278
Well, I thought that may be the case, but do we know any more specifics?
>>
File: 1397790030702.jpg-(33 KB, 640x360, Whatyousee.jpg)
33 KB
33 KB JPG
>>31550143
Glancing out the door and to the almost visible vapor trail that the strange girl left behind, you decide to meet her in the quad like she asked. It wasn’t like she was asking to meet you in a back alley on a moonless night wearing nothing but a dark cloak. It was the quad, in broad daylight. It’s nothing to worry about.

Gathering up your books, you take the time to let everyone else file out in front of you, before heading to the quad. It takes you a little while to get there, despite you going to meet her it’s not exactly something you’re looking forward to with eagerness and joy.

Finally making it, you look around, wondering where Kaede ran off too and what the hell she was doing. You wait for five minutes before you see her, long hair billowing behind her as she heads right towards you. Before you can get a word out she seizes your wrist, dragging you away. You start to resist, but then realize she’s simply dragging you towards the tables that you sat at with Kaede.

Thrusting you at one of the benches, she sits down in front of you, skirt sliding up to show plenty of leg that you probably shouldn’t be thinking about at the moment. She rummages into her bag, before pulling out another ridiculously old looking book and thrusting it into your face.

“Is this what you saw?” she asks, thrusting it into your face.

Well, is it?

>Yes.
>No, it was more female.
>Kinda.
>Other.

>I've noted the lack of response, but It's working fine for me at the moment and I'm not sure when I'll be able to run again, so we'll keep going for right now. If there are any major issues we can work on them when everything is better.
>>
>>31550029
>No, it was more female.
More plump, more curvy, and I bet it gave better hugs than that thing.
>>
>>31550282
I think as long as you don't refresh the page, you should be able to post.
>>
>>31550282
>No, it was more female
>...Well, it became more female maybe?
>>
>>31550281

Nope. If anybody did know anything, they're probably blocked out from commenting on it.

>>31550282

Ummm, not really. it was more... white. like, paper white. no face. and, it had a sundress on. that was, of course, after it started shapeshifting to a more human look.
>>
>>31550282
>Kinda, it was more female though.
And more dressed in white. Though it was tall like what I see in this picture...
>>
>>31550282
>>No, it was more female
>>
>>31550291
are you trying to stir shit with her? seriously?
>>
>>31550282
no. less arms, female, and more... Friendly?
>>
>>31550282
>>No, it was more female.
>>Kinda.
It did shapeshift, but before it was clearly eldritch
>>
For people with captcha problems, there is a workaround in chrome >>>/g/41439598

hopefully that cross link worked
>>
>>31550297
This sounds detailed enough for her, if we throw in what she looked like before she started morphing to look human. We should mention how she literally changed texture when she grabbed us.
>>
>>31550282
No, it was more female.
>>
>>31550277
Same here.
>>
>>31550309
and that she started out very cold, and grew more warm.
also the fact that she was much less malevolent seeming than that.
>>
>No, it was more female.

Also, If you're using firefox and can't post, get noscript, or remove 4chan's exception if you have it already.

If you have chrome, open Java console under tools, hit the settings gear on the console that pops up, and check "disable Java" before closing the console.

Refresh the page and you should be able to post from the top of the page, but not quick-reply.
>>
>>31550314
>>31550277
have you guys refreshed the page recently? if not, then don't.
>>
>>31550297
Pretty sure she had a face in the last dream
>>
>>31550322
Think it was more a suggestion of a face
>>
>>31550322
well, she grew the face, she started out with just a white slate.
>>
>>31550282
>No, it was more female.
"couple other differences too, like that one's got more arms and is less distinct. More importantly, this one, i don't know, "feels" more wrong I guess? not something I can really put my finger on, just a vibe"
>>
>>31550322
Yes, its was a rather nice face too
>>
Looks like you're telling her everything.

Writing.
>>
>>31550331
never mind, i read back, and when we first saw her in that dream she had a face.
>>
>>31550348
Eh, can't hurt.
And she's not killing us, so that's nice.
>>
>>31550348
>inb4 slendy-chan is the reason she hates men
>>
>>31550361
That'll be fine, since slendy-chan >>>>>> psycho lesbian.
>>
>>31550361
jesus, that might be it. She's Captain Ahab who was touched innapropriately by Moby Dick, so she's studying Mysticism to hunt it down and all it's siblings. She smelt Slendy-Chan on us and panicked.
>>
>>31550361
I think it'd be funny if slenderman raped her (oh god what has the internet done to me).
See the novel "Slenderbone" for more details.
>>
>>31550361

And she also thinks that we slept with Slendy.
>>
Slendy-chan a qt
>>
File: 1397791159558.gif-(1.65 MB, 290x260, 1330997496384.gif)
1.65 MB
1.65 MB GIF
>>31550370
>She's Captain Ahab who was touched innapropriately by Moby Dick

You're killing me, anon.
>>
>>31550204
John Galt's priorities:
1) Stay alive and protag
2) Build relationships
3) Become magical Batman
4) Biscuits and Gravy
5) Self preservation
6) ???
7) Profit.
>>
Guide, you still around? Odds are you're just typing up, but i'm paranoid with all this Captcha shit.
>>
File: 1397791583991.png-(133 KB, 413x391, youforgotthehat.png)
133 KB
133 KB PNG
>>31550282
“Well, kinda,” you say, looking at the picture, “It was definitely more…female, even from the beginning. It was however that scary looking.”

“There’s more,” she says, pressing you eagerly.

“Well yeah, it started out like that but it…changed,” you say, “It…touched me, started changing itself to fit my perception of what was right, made itself more palatable to my senses.” You decide leaving out exactly how palatable for the moment, at least the explicit details.

“By the end, it, she, had changer to where she hugged me and changed herself to even feel right, skin, temperature, everything. That’s when she invited me into a bed, fully clothed,” you add that part to prevent misunderstandings, “and then we fell asleep and I woke up.”

You finish, wondering what’s going on behind Kaede’s eyes as she stares at you.

Then, she starts laughing. It’s almost scary, but it simply holds what seems to be a lot of exhaustion that needs let out.

“Of course,” she says, “of course you’d be the one who’d seen it as well…”

Wait, that means she’s seen it as well. Opening your mouth to ask her about it you freeze as she whips around and locks eyes with you again.

“You’ll tell me next time you see it,” she says harshly, hands reaching up to grab your collar but pausing and then lowering themselves to her knees, “I mean…” she swallows obviously fighting back whatever dislike of you she has.

“I mean, please, let me know next time you see it, as soon as possible.”

Well…that was unexpected. How do you respond?

>Sure Kaede, I’ll let you know.
>No.
>Sure but…(insert demand.)
>Other.
>>
>>31550448
>>31550447
well, that was a prompt reply. good to know I'm needlessly paranoid.
>>
>>31550379
Well, we did nap with slendy-chan, that's kinda right?
>>
>>31550448
>Sure but…please stop freaking out all the time and trying to kill me
>And don't sneak into my bed at night, it causes problems
>>
>>31550448
>Sure but…(insert demand.)
I want to know your favorite food, so I can cook it if you ever get spooked like this again.
Smile radiantly
>>
>>31550448
>Sure but, don't go trying to kill me whenever I touch a female
>>
>>31550448
Sure, but only if you promise not to murder me first.
*insert joking laugh*
>>
>>31550448
>>Sure Kaede, I’ll let you know.
(lie)
"and now i really should be going. cya!"
>>
>>31550458

"Only Tatsuko is allowed to sneak into my bed at night."
>>
>>31550448
>Sure but…(insert demand.)

Why? What's going on?
>>
>>31550459
Friends through food, I like.
>>
>>31550448
we really should ask her why she needs to know about it, or even what it is. If she's got ill intentions towards Slendy-chan, we need to know.
>>
>>31550476
ANYONE BUT YOU is allowed to sneak into my bed at night

even the annoying ninja
>>
>>31550448
>Sure but…(Please chill on the trying to kill me thing, please.)
>>
>>31550448
>Other
What do you mean youve seen it too?
>>
>>31550448
>Sure but...
No attempts to kill me, any other members of the gang or Hat-chan. Please?
>>
>>31550448
Sure but mind telling me what you know about it/them?
>>
>>31550477

This you plebs we want info.
>>
>>31550487
Too far, anon, too far.
>>
GODDAMMIT YOU IDIOTS ASK HER WHAT'S GOING ON!

THIS IS WHY WE HAVE STUPID HAREM PROTAGONISTS!
>>
File: 1397791978278.jpg-(39 KB, 407x407, Ain't Mah Nigga.jpg)
39 KB
39 KB JPG
>>31550487
>even the annoying ninja

get out.
>>
>>31550477
yeah, I'm gonna change my vote to this, from this:>>31550467
>>
>>31550533
>>31550513

THANK YOU. Jesus, you people don't even know how to play this game, do you? We don't know if she's trying to kill Slendy-chan, or if Slendy-chan is a Psychopomp, or if Slendy is dangerous, or what! AND YOU WANT TO LET OUR PRIME SOURCE OF INFORMATION WALK?
>>
>(other) I'm John Galt and what the fuck is going on.

I remember some anon from an earlier thread saying that this was our catchphrase.
>>
>>31550448
>Sure but…(insert demand.)
What exactly is going on? Can you tell me anything?
>>
>>31550507
Seconding the "sure, but can I get some context here?"
>>
>>31550573
we don't have a catchphrase, yet. disregard that advice.
>>
>>31550553
>Kaede
>prime source of anything except crazy

I'd sooner trust the brown bimbo that got in our way last session.
>>
>>31550553
>>31550533
>>31550513
Whelp, now I feel dumb as shit, changing vote to ask for why. Gotta protect slendy-chan.
>>
>Sure, but what do you know about Hasshaku-same?
>>
Looks like a sure but asking what she knows about it as well.

Writing.
>>
>>31550593
She's crazy, but she knows about what Slender-chan is. that makes her valuable to us until we can actually communicate with her outside of hugging.
>>
>>31550606
Test.
>>
>>31550615
Testicle
>>
Be advised, the fixes posted earlier in the thread no longer work.

The only way to get captcha back if you don't see it is to turn off javascript through either noscript or options.
>>
>>31550607
I betting on the next dream we have with Slendy she will at least start saying words and/or very short, blunt sentences
>>
...wait, if she's seen what we've seen, does that mean we are both remedial level at summoning?
>>
>>31550656
?
that was mysticism class that we saw slendy-chan in.
We're literally in the same Summoning class. so, I'd assume we're the same in that.
>>
>>31550656
remidial Mysticism, not summoning.
>>
>>31550656
Mysticism. Or maybe, we were so fucking awful, we did something really good.
>>
seeing if captcha at the top will fix problems
>>
>>31550674
Ah, okay. Then summoning won't be the danderous dunce team, good.
>>
>>31550674
Aren't we in basic everything, save for Enchanting though?
>>
>>31550776
*basic*ally
HAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHA
>>
>>31549460
We should summon our familiar.
Having it around increases our mana pool, getting on better relationship with it makes us stronger, and besides all the practical reasons. its cool as hell.
>>
>>31550776
Very true. It's just that she's not going to have seen it through being fuck-terrible at mysticism. But we probably already knew that since she has a picture of it.
>>
>>31550791

He needs to lose the hats and monocle. He looks like a douchenozzle with them on.
>>
>>31550791
lol nope
Jenkins sux

we'll just enchant all day erry day
>>
>>31550791
We do not need a wisecracking talking skull sidekick. We do not need it so much that the show has surely forgotten it exists by now, as it should.
>>
>>31550791
I'd rather work towards better summons
>>
>>31550816
But what if we start scrimshawing enchantments into him? He could be a mobile weapons platform.
>>
>>31550839
Or we could do that to ourselves, and make ourselves a mobile weapons platform.
>>
>>31550839

We need to get better at bullshit ancient enchanting magic, then we can just apply enchantments to nothing and they still work.
>>
Anyone else have trouble posting? the capcha doesn't show up in the floating boxes on chrome or firefox. On firefox I can go to the top of the page to post SOMETIMES (the verification requires extra steps with copy pasting a verification code, but the place to paste it in only sometimes shows up). on chrome that doesn't work at all (never shows up)

>>31550791
>>31549460
Another idea
this is a magic battle school, yes?
it simply has to have some dungeons filled with monsters, traps, and ancient artifacts... which we can explore with our 'gang" (and maybe get some more coherent plot going on based on rather there merely "slice of life in college with magic"
>>
>>31550811
>>31550816
>>31550821
>>31550828
I'm pretty sure that, if we actually payed a little attention to him, he'd actually become bearable, and he'd be the best choice for a bro to confide in
I still hold that he should develop a habit of summoning himself without our consent
>>
>>31550851
That would be incredibly painful. How would we even get the skin off our skull?
>>
>>31550851
>Or we could do that to ourselves, and make ourselves a mobile weapons platform.
can't, you can only make temp enchantments on living things. Perm enchantments require objects. I don't know if a skeleton counts as living or object
>>
>>31550448
Well, it’s not like telling her will hurt anything, at least you don’t see how. Plus it might actually let you in on what exactly it/she is or at least give you an idea.

“Sure,” you say, getting a brief glimmer of what you think is thanks from her, “But can you tell me what you know about it? Why you’re interested?”

It’s here that you see Kaede immediately clamp up, shut down and go into cryo-freeze. It’s not particularly directed at you, your question surely, but not directly at your person. Well, maybe a little bit at you but it’s more of a side-effect than anything deliberate.

You can see Kaede wrestle with herself, probably deciding whether to tell you or not. But in the end she cracks just a little.

“Why, why you don’t get,” she says, sounding closer to the terrified girl of this morning than the evil psycho of dome ventilation, “only one other person knows and it’s going to stay that way.”

She takes a deep breath, then keeps talking.

“What it, they, she,” she chuckles at this, “are, I’m not sure. I’ve studied nearly everything I could get my hands on and even the old mystics don’t have much on them, or even know if there is a “them”.”

“But what they can agree on is that they’re beyond our plane of existence, extremely powerful and that they rarely deign to interact with us.” She sighs. “Beyond that, you probably know just as much or more than I do.”

Well, that was…helpful, kinda. Plus she avoided half of your question.

>Just say thanks.
>Dig deeper.
>Ask something else? (Insert question.)
>Other.
>>
>>31550851
Scrimshawed familiars are probably more durable, and depending on what we enchant, enchantment failure could be very embarrassing/painful for us.

...

We need to enchant our clothes with weak shields. That way, when our (often female) opponent gets past our sweet sweet swordsmanship, she'll get an eyeful as our clothes disintegrate, which could give us and edge, since she'll be distracted by how swole we are.
>>
>>31550881

>Dig deeper.


"Look, I want to know why you're so interested. It's the only way I'll cooperate."
>>
>>31550881
>Dig deeper.

>>31550879
If you can't enchant yourself you can't enchant a summon.

>>31550865
So we need to be bare bones to enchant? I don't think it works like that.

>>31550861
nope fuck that loser
he's gonna be the character the producer forgot about
>>
>>31550881
Are they dangerous? Is that why you're interested in them? Did they hurt somebody you cared about?
>>
>>31550881
>Just say thanks
Hey, getting this much conversation out of her was already pushing it. We can get more out of her later
>>
>>31550894
>she'll get an eyeful as our clothes disintegrate, which could give us and edge, since she'll be distracted by how swole we are.


only in anime
sigh
>>
>>31550881
Dig in like kriegers.
>>
>>31550881
>Just say thanks.

Lets go find Tatsuko and take a nap. This shit is exhausting.
>>
>>31550860
people are posting in other threads about it too, captchas are completely fucked at the moment.

OP, can you please pause this quest until 4chan servers get fixed and people can post reliably?
>>
>>31550894
This is some Chippendales shit right here. I like it.
>>
>>31550881
"That is worrying. Could you recommend a book on them?"
>>
>>31550861
I feel the same, we are really missing a bro opportunity here.
And think about it, as a skeleton he won't compete with us for girls, either. So we don't have to share.
>>
>>31550881
>>Just say thanks.
Let's not trigger her PTSD again
>>
>Just say thanks.

Her revealing something like this is a major plot point, we won't accomplish anything other than pissing her off an losing the few affection points we have with her.

At least wait until we get the opportunity to chuck a bunch of protag points at the situation.
>>
>>31550925
Goin with this, getting the comfy on.
>>
Can we summon Jenkins later and make him listen to us?

And make him lose the Hat and monocle?
>>
>>31550881
>Just say thanks.
Gotta work it up with her. She had the freak out this morning. No sense in triggering round 2
>>
>>31550963
>losing the few affection points we have with her.

I hadn't considered that. Changing my vote to

>dig deeper

in the hope she leaves us the hell alone.
>>
>>31550973
I agree, we should have a heart to floating skull with Jenkins some time.
If nothing else, to establish what we can get him to do with minimal fuss.
>>
>>31550881
>>Just say thanks.
>>
>>31550881
Just say thanks.
she is opening up. don't ruin it.

also, some of our harem are VERY close to permanent tier.
We should spend more time romancing them because getting them to permanent. It will grant us a unique boon, a large increase in protag point generation, they will stop eating up our protag points, and their relationship won't decay over time anymore (although it can still decay if we mistreat them)
>>
>>31550973
>Can we summon Jenkins later and make him listen to us?
yes pls
>And make him lose the Hat and monocle?
the fuck? those things are AWESOME.
>>
Looks like just saying thanks wins by a little bit.

Also, you can summon Jenkins if you want, but it'll still require a consensus.
>>
>>31551034

No, they're pretty dumb. Why we ever went along with it in the first place is beyond me.
>>
>>31550925
>Lets go find Tatsuko and take a nap
Capital idea, I support this.
>>
>>31551045
Because some of us have a sense of humor.
>>
>Thank her

Fuck the new Captcha thing.
>>
>>31551068

Except it's not funny.
>>
>>31551043

I vote no. Jenkins a shit.

Actually, is it possible to replace familiars? I'm not calling for a vote on that, just curious as to if it can be done.
>>
Summon Jenkins.

C'mon...
>>
>>31551094

I'm fine with the Skull bit that wisecracks. The Hats and monocle have to go though.
>>
>>31551043
If we get half an hour in relative privacy, I vote for reconciling with Leeroy Jenkins.
>>
>>31551043
Jenkins is pretty terrible, so no. Frankly he is the only thing I actually DESPISE in this quest
>>
>>31551106

I'm just curious. Is it impossible, difficult, taboo? Or is it something that happens all the time and we just don't know?

Is it an option, even though it might be complex and difficult?
>>
>31551043

No to summoning jenkins
yes to naptime with one of the girls
>>
>>31551097
Jenkins, please tell me how to deal with women. You were a womanizer in life you should know
>>
>>31551043
yes, summon him
>>
>>31551043
no summoning.
>>
Can we ask our summoning teacher if it's possible to unbind a familiar?
>>
>>31551043
I'd rather hang out with Tatsuko now and summon Jenkins to talk with next time we cook something for the house.
>>
>>31551043
no summon
>>
>Hey guys, let's do something stupid to try and piss of the other half of the players!

Really guys?

No Jenkins, please god no Jenkins. I would rather put my testicles through a paper-shredder than deal with that shit. Cutsey irritating little fucks like him getting shoehorned places is the worst thing.
>>
>>31551043
Thats a negative to the summoning.
>>
was this our last class of the day or do we have another class to go to right now?
>>
>>31551204

We're going to have to summon him if we're going to get rid of him.
>>
>>31551213
we have...3 classes left.
Enchanting
PT
Mysticism
>>
>>31550881
You want to push, want to ask why she knows what she does, why she reacted…why she asked you politely to tell her when you would’ve expected her to just throttle you and demand that you tell her. But something stops you. You either in character or perhaps even in your aware state, that pushing Kaede on this would be a bad decision.

Something about how her eyes look at you, or maybe the memory of earlier that morning makes you decide that you can leave this alone, for now, and perhaps fix things up to where you aren’t worried about her murdering you in your sleep. So you let it drop.

“Thanks Kaede,” you say honestly, your voice being as friendly as you can with the girl. You see her relax a little as you say that, like she had been ready for you to pry and was waiting to burst at you.

She takes a deep breath, and then manages “You’re welcome,” before looking away, stuffing the book back into her bag and standing up.

“I’ll see you…at the house,” she says slowly, obviously trying to be polite, on the outside at least, seeing as how you apparently have something she wants.

With that she turns and walks away, towards where you remember the cafeteria being. Checking your watch, you still have a good deal of time before your next class.

>Follow after Kaede, get some food.
>I think some trees and maybe a Tatsuko are in my future.
>Go home for a bit.
>Other
>>
>>31551254
>I think some trees and maybe a Tatsuko are in my future.
For cuddles AND protection
>>
>>31551254
>>I think some trees and maybe a Tatsuko are in my future.
>>
>>31551254
>Trees and Tatsuko
>>
>I think some trees and maybe a Tatsuko are in my future.
>>
>>31551254

>I think some trees and maybe a Tatsuko are in my future.

unrelated to that, posting with this new captcha fucking sucks.
>>
>>31551254
>I think some trees and maybe a Tatsuko are in my future.
we need a bodyguard right now.
>>
>>31551254

>Follow after Kaede, get some food.
Don't sit with her if theres anyone else we know
in fact, maybe after we get lunch we can go to the trees and maybe encounter a wild tatsuko

>>31551225
well we could just ignore him forever
worked out so far
>>
>>31551254
Tatsuko's tats ahoy!
>>
>I think some trees and maybe a Tatsuko are in my future.
We can summon Jenkins later, preferably after ranking up in summoning so maybe he won't be such a prick.. Maybe..
>>
>>31551254
>>I think some trees and maybe a Tatsuko are in my future.
plus anybody else in the harem on break
>>
>>31551281

Eh, sure.

I would like a different familiar then. Or modify Jenkins enough.
>>
>>31551254
had an idea. if we have a crockpot, head home and set something to simmer, then ward it so that people don't break into it before it's ready.

If not, let's grab a bite. wait a moment so Kaede doesn't think we're creeping on her.
>>
>>31551308
well I mean, our focus is enchanting, so summoning is kinda worthless.
>>
>>31551254
>Grab shank making materials from the cafeteria then head out to find Tatsuko.
>>
>>31551320

I dunno. Summoning swords and enchanting them on the spot would be pretty awesome.
>>
>>31551334
nah, just get a Corvo-esque folding sword.
>>
>>31551320
>so summoning is kinda worthless
Because being able to call forth a sword or a creature (summonable waifus) when you need them are such terrible things
>>
>>31551322
>shank
Huh, meant to write "snack", probably time for me to sleep.
>>
>>31551343

I'd rather we didn't stay an idiot savant enchanter forever. The other schools of magic are probably required to unlock more of that bullshit ancient magic stuff, anyway.
>>
Looks like you guys want afternoon shade cuddles.

Writing.
>>
>>31551355
>>31551322

>"Hey cuddlebug, you wanna play a little game?"
>>
>>31551334
on the spot enchantments will always be far shittier than enchantments we take time on

>>31551349
>wanting to summon a sword when we can just carry one
>wanting to summon waifus in a fucking harem quest
>a HAREM quest

keep on perpetuating that namefag reputation buddy
>>
>>31551381

Doesn't matter if we enchant our swords to explode.

>>31551343

Maybe. I'd rather we first start working on speed enhancements. Bind it into our arms and legs to make us faster. Or just enchant our shoes to make us move very fast when activated.
>>
>>31551381
>>31551381
>wanting to summon a sword when we can just carry one
Because you can just carry a sword everywhere on a school campus or into town

OH WAIT, you can't
>>
>>31551412
well. I'm gonna say that's wrong, given that literally everyone is walking around with the equivalent of an assault rifle's worth of power at their fingertips.
>>
>>31551254
>Follow after Kaede, get some food.
>>
Karasuba carries her sword everywhere, just saying.
>>
>>31551397

>Doesn't matter if we enchant our swords to explode.

Do we get to yell "CALADBOLG" when we do so?
>>
>>31551374

Guide, I just want you to know that this thread is the only reason I'm dealing with 4chan right now.

Captcha is beyond fucked.
>>
>>31551397
If we are gonna enchant it to explode why even summon a sword? Just pick up a rock and enchant that.


>>31551412
mmmmhhmmmmmmm
If you could go ahead and read the archives before just jumping in that would be swell, mmmkay?

or even just read >>31551343
>>
>>31551446
Nigga, I bought a pass for this thread.
>>
>>31551456
Same here. This and Shadow Quest are the only reason I shelled out the big 20.
>>
>>31551441

Well yeah, but that's Karasuba. Who's going to try and take it?

But if we're allowed to just carry weapons, I vote we enchant a shotgun to shoot some kind of Riot-foam bouncy-ball shit with Mana fueled impact.

Someone fucks with us, put them in a hamster ball and send them careening across campus.
>>
>>31551412
you fucking retarded namefag, have you even been following the quest? this is a battle school, other students carry weapons around, no one's gonna bat an eye if we have a sword

>>31551441
case in point
>>
>>31551450

Also, we should diversify a little. We may be a savant, but we really shouldn't stay one.
>>
>>31551456

Yeah, I can't justify the money for one with mods being as inconsistent as they are on this site.
>>
>>31551479
That's why we're training with Karasuba. We're diversifying into physical
>>
>>31551474
Oh my god, that's glorious. but I feel as though we shouldn't keep something so obvious with us.
>>
>>31551412
>Because you can just carry a sword everywhere on a school campus or into town
point, it also can be knocked out of your hard.
That being said, I think we should enchant a sword with:
1. invisibility to muggles (carry it everywhere)
2. being really awesomely powerful
3. returning (if it gets knocked out of your hand, it flies back like mjolnir)

that solves those issues, but better
>>
>>31551481
That's a fair opinion. It's ridiculously convenient now that I have one, though.
>>
>>31551479
We're in an anime, remember? Diversifying from savant never works well.
>>
>>31551433
>>31551450
>>31551478
If you had been paying attention, you would have recalled every time one of the girls got a weapon to use, they were all via summoning. They ain't walking around with them out in the open all willy-nilly

Except Karasuba but i mean who's going to stop her that teacher
>>
>>31551497
but why shouldn't we also diversify into regular magic, though? We need to be the ultimate mage if we're going to do all the shit we will inevitably come up with.
>>
>>31551499
>Using the word muggle
Kill yourself, seriously.
>>
>>31551499
1. pretty sure that there are no "muggles" just not magically talented. plus, >>31551343 solves that issue pretty quick
2. well... duh.
3. I like the way you think.
>>
>>31551498

Folding stock, pistol grip, short barrel. Fits right inside a normal bookbag.

Seriously, if it'll carry a 17" laptop or bigger, it will carry a trimmed folder.
>>
>>31551522
see >>31551507

>>31551516
other teachers? the principal? the police? the military? If it was illegal she'd be stopped.
>>
>>31551522
It's a ton of work that pays off very little compared to making sure we're physical and enchanting gods? The only one that might be useful is summoning, and that's only because we need a sword to sword things.
>>
>>31551507
good point. in anime where the hero has a special power he never grows to be a balanced character, but finds more crazy ass uses for his special power

>>31551522
We are a character in an anime, anime follows tropes. ultimately our goals are
1. have fun
2. keep the show running
3. earn protagonist points

So rather than doing the most rational thing we would likely follow some tropes.
then again, this could be a deliberate inversion or deconstruction.
>>
>>31551526
Not the guy you replied to, but do you have a better word to use?
No, seriously. If you have one that has less syllables than "non-magical person" or "unaware of magic" that's better than muggle, I'd use it.
>>
>>31551583
Mundane. Short, simple, and not from Harry Potter
>>
>>31551554
>It's a ton of work

Yeah, no shit, we're in a magical fucking university for exactly that.
>>
>>31551583
how about "ungifted" "normal" or "average"
>>
>>31551601
not from harry potter shouldn't even matter
>>
>>31551579
Trying to learn other magic would make a good episode about the use(ful/less)ness of hard work, guts, and determination. That stuff fits right into an anime.
>>
>>31551613
no, we're in an anime for the purpose of entertaining folks. studying and normal college stuff is not entertaining.
>>
>>31551579
>>31551546
>>31551554

We're a Self-aware Harem Protagonist able to defy conventions of his genre while still maintaining an interesting plotline. Why wouldn't we put in the elbow grease to make sure we're not totally useless in everything except being a wrench monkey swordsman?
>>
File: 1397797210198.jpg-(1.47 MB, 2500x2688, fi-02.jpg)
1.47 MB
1.47 MB JPG
>>31551554
>The only one that might be useful is summoning, and that's only because we need a sword to sword things.
and in that case it would be better to take a sword and enchant the everloving fuck out of it than...
holy shit. sentient sword.
... sentient swordgirl!

damn this should have totally been our familiar
>>
>>31551583
Why not just make it invisible entirely? It makes us stick out less, except to the people who can see it, and those who can see it will treat us the same as if it was visible.

Plus, it would be really annoying to fight someone with an invisible sword. Doubly so if we make it so we can change its shape or length mid battle.
>>
File: 1397797220179.jpg-(386 KB, 797x595, Shessharingthough.jpg)
386 KB
386 KB JPG
>>31551254

Letting out a long, deep sigh as Kaede walks away from your incredibly un-shanked, shot or beaten body, you decide that once again, those trees look damn comfy. Plus, you might get another visit from your own blue-haired cuddle buddy.

Grabbing your bag, you head over to the same spot you slept in the other day. Setting your bag down, you wonder if you should get better at summoning just so you can get a comfy pillow at will. But then you set your head down on the grass and decide that it’s plenty comfy already and that having a pillow would just ruin the whole calm, peaceful vibe you have going.

Closing your eyes as you relax, you don’t think it’s even a minute before you hear a few steps approaching you, then a soft body resting itself against you. Then you feel another one. Opening your eye, you spot the familiar head of blue hair that you expected, along with some black hair that you didn’t.

“Hello,” Akeno says with a giggle as she looks up from where she’s laying in a near mirror position from Tatsuko. “I had it on good authority this was a good place for an afternoon nap.”

“Well, I enjoy it,” you say with a smile.

This gets you a happy murmur from Tatsuko, who seems to think you’re the best pillow ever from how she’s laying on you.

“I thought you might,” says Akeno teasingly, along with tracing a finger down your side. “But then again I’m not sure we should stay here, a scary brute might take advantage of two vulnerable maidens like us.”

A vulnerable maiden…is exactly how not to describe either one of the girls hanging off your sides at the moment. But you don’t have to tell them that.
>Play along.
>Tell them exactly what you think would happen to any such “beast”
>Tell her she’d like it.
>Other
>>
>>31551636
>Play along.
>>
>We're a Self-aware Harem Protagonist able to defy conventions of his genre while still maintaining an interesting plotline. Why wouldn't we put in the elbow grease to make sure we're not totally useless in everything except being a wrench monkey swordsman?
A swordmaster is going to win most fights against mages unless its a really powerful one, and for those we have allies and we can make ourselves a bitching suit of magical armor.
So we wont be useless at all.
>>
>>31551636
>Play along.
>>
>>31551636
>>Play along.
>>
>>31551635

We could call it Invisible Air.
>>
File: 1397797379825.jpg-(133 KB, 468x720, Whistlesinnocently.jpg)
133 KB
133 KB JPG
>>31551634
>>
>>31551629
why would we bother when we don't have to?
>>
>>31551636
>Tell her she’d like it.

Lewd.
>>
>>31551636
>You two are Aware, aren't you? Am I making any huge mistakes? Besides pointing this out, I mean.
>>
>>31551636
>play along

>>31551658

Not saying we'd be useless, because having those two under our belt is pretty damn useful. I'm saying we should be better than useless at MORE than just those two. we don't necessarily need to be the best at them, but enough to pull our weight as well.
>>
>>31551636
>Play along
>>
>>31551636
>Play along.
>Tell them exactly what you think would happen to any such “beast”
>Tell her she’d like it.
I am pretty sure options two and three ARE playing along.
>>
>Tell her she’d like it.

Very yes.
>>
>>31551636
>Play along.
>>
>>31551636
I assume 'Play Along' is the 'tease back' option? if so, yes. if not, we need to physically tease her as well. dangerous finger tracing, go!
>>
>>31551680

Yeah, why should we try to gain more skills and capabilities? are you really this retarded?
>>
>>31551710
ooh my.. so lewd
>>
>>31551634

But Fi was the worst part of the game.

No one liked her, and she would routinely stop you to tell you something you already know, or tell you in the middle of a fight that your health is low.

If SwordWaifu is anywhere close to Fi, I will samefag until she is melted back into scrap metal.
>>
>>31551636
>Play along
>Tell her she’d like it..
these two together ring of some nice lighthearted snark
>>
>>31551636
>play along

Wow, that payed off. But I guess Akeno is probably right to be worried about us just laying down when we're now campus's #1 most wanted guy.
>>
>>31551712
Harem show. If we really tried, we could write the danger out of existence before it shows up.

But you guys are so into your battle animes.
>>
>>31551722

We totally thought about that though. We just went to take a nap in public. Anybody who might want to grab us would be like "Wow, that guy's just taking a nap in public despite the risks. He must be a badass, we should leave."

And then they totally would.

And if that fails, we throw the cuddlebug at them and run away screaming.

And we should say exactly this if she brings it up.
>>
>>31551722
They've clearly made an alliance as waifus, it's why they're together all the time. An agreement to share screentime and not get in each other's way by teaming up to win da John.
>>
>>31551712
>Wants to waste time on stuff we don't needs
>Asks if I'm the retarded one for pointing out we don't need it

Summer came early again!
>>
Looks like you're playing along with Akeno's little scenario.

Writing.
>>
>>31551763

So, yes. Noted.
>>
>>31551740
>Animu harem swhow
it is actually a BATTLE animu harem show.
Harem shows are almost always draped on top of some other story.
Like Techi Mouyo GXP is draped across a space opera.
Negima is draped across a magical battle school.
etc

Fighting some BBEGs would be a good way for us to bond with our team as well as earning protag points.
... how about hard mode of having a BBEG that is genre saavy and follows the evil overlord list?
>>
>>31551782
remember to tease her back. Dangerous Fingers need to be on both sides of the equation.
>>
>>31551794
You mean, the Antagonist is Aware as well, and reacts to everything we do in the intelligent way? Do it. Guide, Are you taking notes here?
>>
>>31551760
>And if that fails, we throw the cuddlebug at them and run away screaming.
the what now?
this reminds me, since almost all enemies are bound to be girls we can probably do a lewd escape maneuver (aka, girl tries to drag us away... pull down her skirt. she will be too busy trying to cover up and we could escape in the confusion).
although this would probably have negative consequences for us, especially because we didn't go with the pervert motif (why didn't we?)
>>
>>31551810
Of course. But I've got a bunch of stuff ready that you haven't even scratched the surface of yet.
>>
>>31551794
>BATTLE animu harem show
Yes, and we could have stopped that if we tried, earlier. If we blew enough points, I'm sure we could stop it right now. Reminder that Akeno was the one who introduced the battle bullshit in the first place.

Speaking of points, I kinda wish we had blown some on this scene.
>>
>>31551788
Bro, if you still can't understand why it's useless to do what you're suggesting then you're a lost cause. I'd be careful about calling others retards from that glass house though.
>>
>>31551821
Fantastic.

Oh, Hey, question. Can an already established character be taken over by Awareness, becoming somebody completely, or can they just realize by the Protag telling them the issue? Or is Awareness decided completely at Chargen?
>>
>>31551794
>Implying the bad guy isn't already following the list.
>Implying that we have not already met the bad guy.
>Implying that the bad guy isn't Tatsuko and the Ninja was right all along.
>>
>>31551846
Do you mean sentience?
>>
>>31551810
>You mean, the Antagonist is Aware as well, and reacts to everything we do in the intelligent way? Do it. Guide, Are you taking notes here?
Actually I meant an NPC who bucks the trend. It has been done before but its still fairly rare thing to see in anime.
However, having him ALSO be a sentient character will be awesome.

... actually, better make it a her. (I already know how we plan to win)

>>31551822
>Yes, and we could have stopped that if we tried, earlier. If we blew enough points
Anon, if we go below 100 protag points we risk losing protag status altogether!
>>
>>31551829
>Learning more magic in a magic battle harem story
>useless

Do you have to concentrate to breath?
>>
>>31551859
well, yes and no. it's really a question of what sentience does in this setting. Does sentience overwrite a character that is already in existence, is it something that can be added on as a perk-type thing, or is it something that can only be decided at Character creation?
>>
>>31551860
>Anon, if we go below 100 protag points we risk losing protag status altogether!
Boo hoo. If our character was experienced and particularly lazy, he probably would have done it in a heartbeat just to keep the genre firmly in slice of life.
>>
>>31551848
>Implying that the bad guy isn't Tatsuko and the Ninja was right all along.
all the more reason to romance her.
we gain victory by giving her the d.
or heck, series that follow the villains are popular. we could always sell out to the dark side

>>31551869
Anon, he explicitly said we should learn more, and only disagreed with you about WHAT we should learn (he thinks we should learn more enchantment and phys. his opponent thought we should become a jack of all trades and dabble in all schools)
>>
>>31551894
>just to keep the genre firmly in slice of life.

Why would you want this to be that horribly boring?
>>
>>31551894
... But we decided on Battle Harem right at the beginning of the Quest. He asked us what kind of setting we wanted and everything, and we went with Battle School harem in College. This was in the cards from thread 1.
>>
>>31551884
Sentience is usually decided at the beginning. But seeing as how you haven't found your first, or even really thought about it much, I'm not sure that I'd fight against you making an existing one aware.
>>
>>31551908
I don't. But a lazy sentient character? I could see them wanting that. Slice of life stories take it easy.
>>
>>31551869
Kid, before making assumptions about how an anime quest would go maybe you should try watching an anime?
>>
>>31551894
>Boo hoo. If our character was experienced and particularly lazy, he probably would have done it in a heartbeat just to keep the genre firmly in slice of life.
1. we voted for battle school with magic. not slice of life. i didn't vote for it but i am not going to sabotage the quest.
2. if we lose protagonist status this means someone ELSE has gained it. This means that that other person is now free to make this NOT a slice of life. changes we make can be easily undone by any future protagonist. and realistically, we would never get another chance like this.
losing protagonist status is quest over
>>
>>31551902
I'm the one who originally suggested the idea, not the anon who kept arguing. I'm not saying we should be Jack-of-all-trades, Master-of-none. We should be Master of all schools. We should definitely master Physical and Enchanting first, but to limit ourselves to just that because 'muh savant' and 'muh tropes' is stupid.
>>
>>31551937
> I'm not saying we should be Jack-of-all-trades, Master-of-none. We should be Master of all schools. We should definitely master Physical and Enchanting first,
then we are in agreement and all we had is a miscommunication and misunderstanding.
>>
>reminder that Tatsuko sought us out at the start

seriously guys if that's not a sentient waifu I don't know what is
>>
>>31551922
alright. The real question was to wonder about how an awareness comes into a series from another. in other words, did John Galt already exist, and we just body-jacked him from the series? and if that happens, could an awareness body-jack, say, Karasuba, and completely change her personality? It adds a kind of 'invasion of the body snatchers' vibe to trying find other sentient characters.
>>
>>31551937
I agree. that was our plan from the start, just work our way through one or two items at a time, in order to create continuous plot arcs, and not become shit in the process of spreading ourselves thin.
>>
>>31551959
well, maybe we're just comfy
>>
>>31551959
No, that was our protag status making us a waifu magnet.
>>
>>31551937
You realize you're shooting our enchanting ability in the foot by doing this, right? We can't pull out bullshit without being a savant.

>making light of tropes
What the fuck. The universe literally runs on those.
>>
>>31551968
If they are aware, they generally remember their past selves and it carries over. So, if a character you met is aware, you probably wouldn't be able to tell at the beginning because they're acting like they're supposed to because they know they're supposed to.
>>
>>31551989
>>31551959

We have Plot. relevant characters are simply drawn into our orbit of their own accord.
>>
>>31552004
This guy is right. He understands what's up. The rest of yall need to remember exactly what kind of quest this is.
>>
>>31552004
Reading comprehension. Do you have it? I specifically said we should master enchanting first.Mastering Summoning doesn't suddenly mean we stop learning Enchanting, either. We don't have an On-Off switch for each skill. We can multitask on a few skills at a time, just like we're doing with Enchanting and Physical.
>>
>>You realize you're shooting our enchanting ability in the foot by doing this, right?

Our enchanting ability is already maxed. Our physical ability is at 3/5. We literally cannot shoot ourselves in the foot with regards to enchanting right now, we can only get stronger by learning new spells and getting a mana pool large enough to cast them.

This >muh tropes bullshit is stupid because not all battle anime follow them religiously, and we specifically picked a self aware character at the start to be able and avoid the more stupid ones.
>>
File: 1397799299873.png-(1.41 MB, 1366x768, Seemstobepayingattentionaswell.png)
1.41 MB
1.41 MB PNG
>>31551636
Deciding to play along with her little game, you take one of your own fingers and place it on her hip, sliding it upwards along her smooth, soft curves slowly as she continues to touch your side.

“If that was the case,” you say, watching your hand as it moves towards so much deliciously formed flesh, “I guess I would have to stand up to that vicious beast and protect two virtuous maidens such as yourselves.”

Akeno giggles at this, apparently wanting to play this for all that it’s worth. “How would you…defend, the two of us from such a big nasty brute.”

You sigh, a big heavy theatrical one that continues the play. “I suppose it would depend upon what exactly that beast wanted from you,” you say, “But I do know that I would engage him most heartily with all of my might, down to my last breath to protect the two of you.”

Even as you say that, you wonder how much is bluster, how much is true and then how much is the show messing with your mind to make you believe it because of standard convention.

But Akeno seems to miss this or ignore it, her finger pausing on your sternum, before pressing slightly.

“I guess that would mean you would deserve a reward,” she says, voice dropping the teasing tone as her finger slides up to your neck, “perhaps…a kiss?”

Now that tone…that tone was not teasing. That was questioning, maybe even…slightly jealous?

>Tell her you’d like that.
>I don’t need a reward.
>You’d want more than that.
>Other.
>>
>>31552049
fuck off retard
we're focusing enchanting with a side of physical
>>
So, all this over a suggestion on swording? Really? c'mon, we were one of the most friendly, non-shitstormy quest threads.
>>
>>31552049
No, you don't understand. Having other skills DOES mean we stop being a one-trick pony with Enchanting, and that means we won't constantly get Enchanting-based bullshit like that shield.
>>
>>31552061
>You’d want more than that.

Wash away the stink of kaede, please.
>>
>>31552061
>Tell her you’d like that.

>>31552055
>we specifically picked a self aware character at the start to be able and avoid the more stupid ones.
Nope! We picked an aware character so we could exploit and take advantage of tropes, not avoid them!
>>
>>31552061
"That sounds like it'd be fun... but would it stop there?"

Tease until she pops. Sexual Chicken up in this bitch.
>>
>>31552061
>Tell her you’d like that.
>>
>Tell her you’d like that.
but we wouldn't want something like that as a reward. We'd want it because she wanted to kiss us
>>
>>31552061
oh shit, just noticed the picture's name.
>tell her you'd like that
>>
>>31552055
>Our enchanting ability is already maxed.
Actually this is not true.
Our enchantment is at the level of "knows everything or has extreme talent" (extremely rare in males). there is another level above it of "knows everything AND has extremely talent"
According to note, no male witch has ever achieved this level in any field ever, yet.
>>
>>31552100
This sounds like the most natural flirting so far. I vote this.
>>
>>31552089
>>31552100
i dunno, this option just feels kinda sleazy
>>
>>31552061
>>I don’t need a reward.

Akeno does not like what she sees.
>>
>You’d want more than that.
But you'll settle for a kiss.
>>
>>31552119

We can't put any more points into the enchanting skill, it's at 5/5. We can learn more spells for the school, but that doesn't require resource expenditures.
>>
>>31552127
what do you mean? I'm pretty sure she's jealous of Kaede for kissing us.
>>
>>31552061
>File name
Oh boy, what could that lead too...
>Tell her you’d like that
>>
>>31552061
would like that.

>>31552089
this is going too far.
>>
>>31552126
Dude, it's asking her in a roundabout way if she wants to, in the future, take it farther. It's not as though we're going to throw her down and ravish her here. Have you ever flirted with a girl before? This kind of brashness appeals to them right in the lizard brain.
>>
>>31552082

Did Guide actually ever say that our bullshit was resulting from savant status?

I always thought it was because we had maxed out enchanting without having any knowledge on the subject whatsoever, so Plot would take over when necessary.

If we had maxed out Physical at the beginning, we'd probably spontaneously start using Solar Hero Style during our first PT class, not because we're muscle savants, but because plot dictates that we develop unheard of abilities spontaneously.
>>
>>31552160
This is talking about a very specific situation. It's essentially the equivalent of telling her she'd be obligated to do more.
>>
>>31552160
>Dude, it's asking her in a roundabout way if she wants to, in the future, take it farther.
>Hey girl, how do you feel about fucking me in the future?
are you stupid? even shonen writers know more about women than that.
either she is ok with it now, or she is not ok. and nothing is a bigger turn off than appearing to be a sperg that has no clue about human relationships.
Also, the fact that she is willing to kiss us at all means that, with 100% certainty, she will be amenable to going further in the future IF we continue to deepen our relationship.
>>
Looks like you'd like that.


Also, you guys seem to be assuming a lot about what I would/would not allow, how much complete bullshit I'm going to allow you to pull and how much/little effort is necessary.
>>
>>31552192
>>31552194
alright, whatever, I give. we'll go the safe way. big risk, big reward I figured.
>>
>>31552204
/tg/ does that
It's my favorite part when a QM tells them "No" and ruthlessly crushes their dreams
please don't disappoint me guide.
>>
>>31552162
oho, that is a good point. plot would have come about in SOME manner

PS. capchas are fixed now
>>
>>31552192
wut.

The entire thing was a little playact flirting. She's asking if we're interested, we're responding with HELL YES. It might be a bit strong, but this isn't some weird 'if i save you, we must fuck' thing.
>>
>>31552230
Thanks for pointing it out.
>>
>>31552162
That might be true, but diversifying just feels like ruining good high-pressure Plot. We could be getting a giant natural geyser and you want to make it several wimpy fountains.
>>
>>31552243
thank you. at least somebody here got the idea. I mean, it's saying, I'll take a kiss, but I won't complain when hormones take us further.
>>
>>31552264
>implying the way to get more ancient magic isn't to become masters of all the schools
>>
Akeno Best Girl, Kiss is Yes.
>>
>>31552061
>Tell her you’d like that.
>Then laugh
>I don’t need a reward.

We can't pretend a kiss from a pretty girl wouldn't be great. But whether we'd get a reward or not wouldn't be the important part.
>>
>>31552061
>Tell her you’d like that.
>>
>>31552264
I feel like we've already somewhat painted ourselves as being an enchanting prodigy, needing to improve physical a lot, and extremely unlucky with mysticism.

I feel like we should obviously keep working on our strengths, and we should improve the basics of everything. With mysticism though, I could see us either sticking with it as our worst subject, or turning it around and studying it a lot to make sense of those weird things we keep finding.
>>
>>31552302
reverse the order and sure
>>
>>31552243
In the ideal situation, with the ideal phrasing.
It is still extremely poor execution to say "i want sex not kiss" rather than just kissing her and then escalating (tongue, ass grab, etc)

However people actually came up with justifications like >>31552160 which show this clearly was not this ideal situation you described.

>>31552213
that isn't what >>31552160 is saying, explicitly
>asking her in a roundabout way if she wants to, in the future, take it farther
this is not something you ever ever ask
>>
>>31551636
>Tell her you’d like that.
>>
>>31552326
I'll be happy as long as none of the girls have required studying on their routes, honestly. That shit's a drag.
>>
>>31552326
we could certainly turn around a subject through hard study and training montage.
but the problem we are bad at three different subjects. doing it for all of them and becoming master of all is a bit much.

then again, we established ourselves as a studious guy who tries to never miss class. and the reason we suck in most subjects is lack of training (most witches were taught since childhood, we started at college because male witches have only been a thing for 3 years)
>>
>>31552061
I am going to be honest.
I expect to get cock blocked by a random event.
>>
Guide, does our character know of any sentient etiquette or is he too young? Like, is he not supposed to ever mention that stuff because he's the protagonist?

also lol at this
>Harem members will not simply fall into your lap.
Totally sentient, Tatsuko. You too Akeno. I'm looking forward to being proven wrong here.
>>
>>31552204
Guide, could you clarify what
>You’d want more than that.
was meant to imply as a response?
>>
File: 1397801204399.png-(1017 KB, 1280x656, Thisclose.png)
1017 KB
1017 KB PNG
>>31552061
You swallow a bit as Akeno’s finger traces your neckline, her eyes now not teasing, but rather more serious, demanding even.

You wonder how exactly to respond to such a statement but in the end, it simply comes down to the truth.

“I think I’d like that,” you say, your voice managing to not go hoarse as you do so.

It’s here that you see Akeno lean up over you, hair falling down over her ears to dangle around your face, while Tatsuko seems to scoot up closer, her face coming near to yours as well. While the impression you get isn’t one of fear, there is a lot of pressure coming towards you.

“Oh you would would you,” she says from over you, voice…seductively angry? “I wonder if you’d like it better than your…previous, encounters.”

It’s here that you can definitely tell, she’s either pissed that you kissed Kaede or pissed that Kaede kissed you first, you’re not sure. But you do know how to respond, even you aren’t that dumb.

“It would be better, infinitely,” you say, face slightly red from the sheer amount of femininity that’s being pressed against you or dangled in your face. If you weren’t red, it’d probably be because you were asexual.

Akeno leans down, at first you think she’s going to kiss you, but she simply whispers in your ear.

“Prove it.”

Her lips are mere inches away from yours now, just hovering over them. But, you’ve been kissed exactly once and you didn’t have much choice in that. Honestly, you’re still nervous. Tatsuko pressing in from the bottom doesn’t seem to help you much either.

Your call.

>Kiss a girl.
>Kiss a girl well. -10 protag points.
>Back down.
>Kiss two girls well -20 protag points.
>Other
>>
>>31552204
>Also, you guys seem to be assuming a lot about what I would/would not allow, how much complete bullshit I'm going to allow you to pull and how much/little effort is necessary.
I am not sure what you mean by this.
are you referring to the guy saying "we could transform this to slice of life by burning protag points"?
or the one saying "lets master every school of magic"?
or the ones saying "we can't because tropes"?
>>
>>31552486
This was never a choice, Guide, and you know that. 20 points fucker. double down, all in.
>>
>>31552486
>>Kiss two girls well -20 protag points.

Worth it
>>
>>31552486

>Two Girls well.

If she just butts in it's hardly our fault.
>>
>>31552486
>>Kiss two girls well -20 protag points.

How can I not?

Can we burn more protag points and do it even better?
>>
>>31552493
Protag points let you do nearly anything. If you all agreed, it could be a SOL show.

I'm not sure why you're bringing in tropes at all.
>>
>>31552486

>Kiss two girls well -20 protag points.

Of course.
>>
>>31552493
I kind of don't want an answer to any of these questions. Our character doesn't know. We shouldn't either.
>>
>>31552486
>Kiss two girls well! A steal for 20 protagonist points!
>>
>>31552486
>Kiss two girls well -20 protag points.
maximum all the way
>>
>>31552486
>>Kiss two girls Really well -30 protag points.

As if there was any other choice
>>
>>31552533
word of Guide confirms, Tropes a shit.
>>
>>31552486
Can we double down on protag points, burn 40 and be amazing?
>>
>>31552486
>Kiss two girls well -20 protag points.


>Implying I wouldn't take this option

Should we get grabby? Pull them closer is what I'm saying.
>>
>>31552533
How much would "Kiss two girls really well, without the inevitable interruption" cost?
>>
>>31552486
>Kiss two girls well -20 protag points.
I didn't know there were other choices
>>
>>31552533

>Nearly anything

Could we do the shotgun thing noted here >>31551474 because that would be a hilarious way of dealing with Mooks.

>John, I'm here to capture-
>Nope, late for class.

And away they fly.
>>
>>31552570
what, are you asking if we can kiss them so well they cream themselves?

hang on can we actually do this? is this a thing?
>>
>>31552523
There's always a choice.

At least it wasn't, in the immortal words of Merc Command, "Chicken out like a beta faggot."
>>
>>31552594
>inb4 hentai harem protagonist
>>
>>31552594
>>31552561
>>31552570

No really though, is this an option? If yes then I'm supporting it.
>>
>>31552486
>Y-you too
>>
>Why is a cosmic horror in my shadow?! Kiss three girls well. -50 protag points

Shadow-chan!!!
>>
>>31552570
I'm gonna veto this. don't wanna be having sex in the middle of a field.
>>
>>31552605
I'll support this as well if its doable
>>
>>31552599
Also, 30 points and I'll let you roll a d100. 1 will simply be "decent". It'll go up from there.
>>
>>31552486
seconding >>31552570
if possible, just spending the 20 if not.
kind of worried both is a trap choice, but it'll be good for plot if nothing else
>>
>>31552605
>>31552620
Backing this up.
>>
>>31552589
I just love the way you describe that scenario. cause, we ain't know class skipping slacker.
>>
>>31552570
Seconding.
>>
>>31552599
Hey, is this:
>>31552594
Possible?
>>
>>31552621
sweet. 30 points ho!
>>
>>31552570
Also supporting this.
>>
Rolled 85

>>31552621
30 points! Lets do this.
>>
>>31552621
yes, lets do this
>>
Rolled 63

>>31552621
I'm game.
>>
>>31552636
Akeno and Tatsuko are classy ladies, not hos.
>>
Rolled 26

>>31552621
yes. all of my fucking yes. go for the fucking wall
>>
>>31552621
Hell yes. I cannot yes this enough.
>>
Rolled 100

>>31552621
Now is the time for you guys to roll 100's.
>>
Rolled 91

>>31552621
and now we have to take this
I mean, we always roll so well
>>
>>31552646
I love you anon
>>
>>31552646
oh hot damn. mah nigga with your wonderful rolls.
>>
Rolled 80

>>31552621
As if there were a choice here.
>>
Rolled 13

>>31552621

AHAHAHHAHAHA
>>
Rolled 63

>>31552599
30 protag points go
>>
>>31552646
Not quiet a hundred. What does below 90 get us? Not quite creaming their skirts?
>>
>>31552621
At this point, why the hell not.
You do realize what you're doing right?
>>
>>31552668

AHAHAHAHA

Guide, can you please take this?
>>
>>31552652
>>31552649
>>31552648
>>31552646
I guess I should mention, that I'm taking rolls after I call for them,


>>31552668
Nah, fuck it. Writing now.
>>
>>31552668
no you!
wait
shit!
>>
>>31552668
...but.... but he only counts the first three...
>>
>>31552668
I don't know if they creamed, but I sure did.
>>
>>31552668

Even the dice want lewd
>>
>>31552696
oh fuck, yes.
ya know, I was actually the guy who suggested that way of taking rolls. it makes me happy that it's getting use.
>>
Rolled 4

>>31552621
>>
>>31552696
oooh baby
>>
>>31552668
Aaaaw! Why couldn't you have been sooner?

>>31552696
>I guess I should mention, that I'm taking rolls after I call for them,

Aw, well-

>Nah, fuck it. Writing now.

AAAAAAAH SHIT, WE GETTIN OUR MACK ON NOW!
>>
File: 1397801975822.gif-(1.79 MB, 200x200, Dancing Colbert.gif)
1.79 MB
1.79 MB GIF
>>31552668
HOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO I DID THAT AND IT COUNTS
>>
>>31552696
Guide, you are good people. Don't let anyone tell you otherwise.
>>
>>31552668
>>31552696

Oh god, I'm so happy I suggested this.
>>
Awesome, we now have a way to gain affection other than cooking.
>>
>>31552668
Please tell me this counts.
>>
>>31552732
WE ARE THE GOD OF KISSING
>>
File: 1397802052616.gif-(675 KB, 480x270, 1393567460525.gif)
675 KB
675 KB GIF
>>31552668
>>
>>31552668
Bullshit powers +1
>>
I have this mental image that we're about to get ambushed, but then our would-be attackers see us going to town and just kinda drooling and forgetting about the trap they were trying to spring.
>>
>>31552668
Just for that, I'll forgive the unnecessary apostrophe.
>>
>>31552751
I don't know why, but that gif made me laugh out loud
>>
>>31552747
we are a domestic god
We can enchant, so we make the home have all those luxuries people want
we cook, making home life bearable
we kiss wonderfully, making our waifus want to come home
and with our bullshit swordsmanship, we can defend our home from interlopers
>>
so... i'm guessing that that 100's gonna put enchantment into the kiss?
>>
File: 1397802135034.jpg-(113 KB, 859x679, 1395452758138.jpg)
113 KB
113 KB JPG
>>31552696
>>
Just so you guys don't get completely out of control.

I AM NOT GIVING YOU PERMANENT MAGIC BULLSHIT KISSING POWERS.

THIS IS JUST FOR THIS SCENE.
>>
>>31552780
Still totally worth it.

can we get a kissing skill, too?
>>
>>31552780

TOO LATE, I'M ALREADY WRITING FANFICTION.
>>
>>31552780
That's kinda what I expected
but hey I mean if you want to give us permanent bonuses feel free
>>
>>31552780

so, in other words, we need to roll another 100 to make it permanent. I get you jib, Guide. we understand.
>>
>>31552780
Actually, this may not be too good of a roll. it means that everything to come is just gonna be a dissapointment.
like that comic about the coffee that stole the guy's chance at a happy life
>>
>>31552780
wouldn't expect you too, that shit's way too powerful in a harem show. From the narrative standpoint, it's probably got something to do with it being our first willing kiss
>>
>>31552780
From now on, I'll push for self enchanting. Then enchanting someone else. Then we'll give them orgasms from kissing.

Let's make it happen people
>>
>>31552780
sensible enough
I am glad it even counted for this scene anyways.

Question, I looked at the mechanics pastebin, if I am reading it correctly, we have to actually spend protagonist points on a girl before she can become a part of our harem?
>>
>>31552801
Nah, that just means we'll have to have a kissing training montage to reach the level of mastery we experienced
>>
>>31552780
Good. It would get silly.
>>
Off topic from the current panic, but how behind this idea are you guys: >>31552589 And can we call it 'the rape whistle'.
>>
>>31552780
>>31552793
help i cant sop laughing. never change /tg/
>>
>>31552824
Retconned that part out, it was dumb. Still working on fixing that part.
>>
>>31552824
no, it only means that if we want more than 5 slots we spend points. Permanent members get removed from the count.
>>
>>31552812
As much as I would like that, Guide did say no smut.
>>
>>31552865
Wait, do permanent members still get removed? thought that changed.
>>
>>31552859
Maybe make it so that she has to be a part of X plot-centric scenes before becoming a permanent member? It'd probably start low, but scale as we get more harem members and "fans" start not really wanting to keep track of more waifus
>>
>>31552780
Awwwwwwwwww.

That's completely fair. Still, I hope we unlock superior kissing as a power eventually. Possible after much practice and experimentation.
>>
>>31552801
presumably we don't roll for every time we kiss a girl we already kissed.
We just have chemistry with this specific girl (well, girls).

... so, after we kiss each one, do they kiss each other?
>>
>>31552887
he hasn't edited that part yet.
>>
>>31552847
Sounds like a bang up idea to me.

>Don't worry love, you'll appreciate joining my gang, I promise.
>I mean, don't do it!
>Or what? All you can do is enchant and you have no where else to run
>I'll take out my rape whistle.
>Even if you enchanted it so your girlfriends could hear it, it won't-
>CH-CHK!
>....
>>
Also, we're way over bump limit and already on page 6. Just a heads up.
>>
>>31552887
So did I.
>>
>>31552890
>That's completely fair. Still, I hope we unlock superior kissing as a power eventually.
I think this would require that every time we have a special kiss moment we roll really well.
alternatively, it might be forever locked due to suspension of disbelief issues with the audience
>>
>>31552847
>>31552901
It would sound like a rape joke which is going to make us seem like a jerk with incredibly bad taste.
>>
>>31552901

Or offer to lend it to someone else, they think the idea is silly until they see it's a Converted Saiga-12.

When someone we don't want in the know asks about the 'rape whistle' we pull a regular whistle on a string out from under our shirt. Then note our concern for being surrounded by hostile attractive women at all hours of the day.
>>
>>31552898
>he hasn't edited that part yet.
he said he hasn't edited the pastebins at all and will be updating them later
the op where he listed the changes didn't specifically state anything about the "spend points to promote them", he only clarified that was gone in >>31552859 as response to question

there is no reason there can't be other rules he changed and hasn't announced yet
>>
>>31552970
we could enchant an actual rape whistle with magic bubbles
>>
File: 1397802885687.gif-(397 KB, 500x267, tumblr_ltvgaueI6f1qf8btuo1_500.gif)
397 KB
397 KB GIF
Shotguns aside, has anyone archived this thread?
>>
>>31552998
I feel like all this is treading into "caster" territory.
>>
>>31552901
>>31552917
>>31552941
>>31552970

I'm not sure about calling it a rape whistle, but the idea of a rocket-hamster-ball inducing shotgun amuses the shit out of me.
>>
>>31553007

Just did.
>>
>>31553033
I think it'd be an ok gag. Once. Beyond that, not too thrilled at the idea.
>>
Or enchant one of those boxcutters to extend to ludicrous length and carry a sword in our pocket.
>>
>>31553033
call it a poke-ball
>>
>>31553065
Gotta catch em all!
>>
>>31553033
yes with a digital display for the number of bounces before it lets them out. 20 ish standard
>>
>>31553025
so, just that i am clear on this
enchanting a shotgun to magically bubble an enemy is enchantment
but doing the exact same thing to a whistle is casting?

>>31553033
agreed

>>31553088
>>31553065
heh

captcha: Brockville
>>
>>31553065
>>31553052
>>31553033

What if we called it something different everytime?

>Rape-Whistle.
>Bitch-B-Gone, Full auto spray 'can'.
>'Plan B'.
>'A Cunning Retort'.

etc.
>>
>>31553112
I like the idea of using a different name every time. i still think that making a rape joke is incredibly bad taste

especially considering one of our roomates is a lesbian who has a PTSD trigger from kissing boys
>>
>>31553128
Actually make all the names exclusively rape jokes. Say them loudly in front of Kaede.
>>
>>31553142
nah. I don't want her in the harem, but I do want her to be our friend. Mainly so we can help her find lesbians and help her get her own harem. That way we can attract more viewers for our show
>>
>>31553128

Eh.... I could see why you might think that, but at the same there's a point where it's less us being insensitive and more them being thin-skinned.

>>31553142

Alright, now I'm voting against rape jokes because Fuck You.
>>
>>31553111
No, I said "all this" in reference to the whole idea. I just got into the discussion.
>>
File: 1397803497836.png-(1.37 MB, 1624x911, One.....png)
1.37 MB
1.37 MB PNG
>>31552486
You’re nervous, fuck are you nervous I mean holy shit is Akeno hot, and she’s right there and she totally wants you to kiss her and you’re probably hyper-ventilating slightly and oh god.

That’s not even mentioning the fact that Tatsuko, who is just as attractive as Akeno is, just in a more sleepy cuddly than darkly suggestive way, is right there as well.

So, doing what you think is possibly the only way to get out of this. You throw a large number of protag points willy nilly into the sky, hoping that it will help you not disappoint the two gorgeous women who seem to be upset at you because you kissed another woman, mostly against your will.

-30 Protag points.

Then you feel something click. It’s not as large as the shield you pulled, but it’s similar to what happened with the sword, except sharper.

Pulling Akeno closer to you, you take her lips like you’d done it before, hundreds, thousands of times before, enough kisses for a very long life that you’d shared together as your hand gently rests on her neck while your lips move against hers. You’re not sure how long it lasts, seeing as how you mostly shut down and enjoy it, but when you break it, you hear her gasp, breathing heavily as you do the same to Tatsuko.

Again, even as your lips touch hers for the first time, you feel, remember doing it so many times before, again enough for a lifetime. The kiss lasts roughly as long as Akeno’s, your brain pretty much stopping logical thought as you kiss the second of the gorgeous women on top of you.

Breaking from Tatsuko, you see her face is red as well, with her letting out a small “Anh,” as you do so.

Looking up, you see Akeno wobble slightly and then apparently decide to lean down on your chest again before her arms lose the strength to hold her up.
>>
>>31553171
what a playa
those past lives sure are useful
>>
File: 1397803599975.jpg-(23 KB, 300x300, 1301_original_jbUHW.jpg)
23 KB
23 KB JPG
Who the fuck cares? It's a stupid joke to giggle over. Now stop using up our bumps goddamnit.
>>
File: 1397803599753.png-(211 KB, 369x581, Two.png)
211 KB
211 KB PNG
>>31553171
“Did I prove it?” you manage to ask her, nearly out of breath yourself.

A breathless “Yes,” is all she can manage as she lays against you, the combined anatomy of both her and Tatsuko pressing heavily against you as they try and catch their breaths.

Even as you enjoy this feeling, a single thought runs through your mind. There’s no way that you kissed that well without having done it before. The ease at which you did that…

But you haven’t kissed them before, you’re pretty sure you’d remember having something like that.

Right?
>>
>>31553183
We have inherited the perverted dreams of a thousand thousand lifetimes, and we shall fulfill them
>>
>>31553188
Wait, are we channeling the lives of previous MCs? ARE WE THE AVATAR OF HAREM MCS PERSONIFIED?
>>
>>31553187

We hit the bump-limit and went auto-sage almost two hundred posts ago.

We're on page SIX.
>>
>>31553188
>Right?

It'll come back to us eventually.
>>
>>31553142
even if you hate her, the other girls will likely not approve of us bullying a girl with obvious ptsd by making rape jokes at her.
>>
And that's it for tonight.

Need to get at least some sleep, so I'll be around for just a little bit for questions etc.
>>
>>31553212
wow holy shit page six
that's at least an hour left, probably 2
>>
>>31553219
This
>>
>>31553212
Actually, ironically enough, your post is exactly the 500th post in the thread.
>>
>>31553244
>ironically
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/ironic?s=t
>>
File: 1397803861108.jpg-(34 KB, 650x650, Awesome-face-4.png.jpg)
34 KB
34 KB JPG
>>31553230
>Kisses for the Mack God! Cuddles for the Lewd throne!

Thanks for the thread Guide.
>>
>>31553235

My point is complaining about using the bumps up became irrelevant a while ago.

>>31553230

Fantastic timing by the way.
>>
>>31553230
Is it possible to replace our familiar? No one likes him.
>>
>>31553230
I assume you'll award us the related points in the next thread?
>>
>>31553230
Shit nigga, I've been waiting a week for this thread, and you did not dissapoint. Questions answered, more questions created, an intense scene with two girls, all leading up to a climactic kiss.
>>
>>31553230

Familiar and Shotgun, two question we'd like answered before you go, if you have time.
>>
>>31553209
we are channeling past lives of the sentient character from different shows. which should be impossible.
(although, maybe we are channeling past lives in character? as in, they aren't from other shows but from other incarnations of john galt in this universe. and we just think its from other shows due to it being the only frame of reference we have)

this actually would fit well with things like BBEG (innocent girl, student channeling past lives of many wicked ancestors)
>>
>>31553261
>coincidental; unexpected
You were saying?
>>
>>31553277
except for all the people who do like him. like the majority who voted for him in the first place
>>
>>31553303
which could lead into an interesting plot point. This is all supposed to be impossible right? Why is it happening then? Did someone actually break the fourth wall?
>>
>>31553230
good times.
and a good time to call it quits, its 3am

>>31553323
oooh... are we really in an anime. or did we get sucked into a fanfiction?
>>
File: 1397804152133.png-(368 KB, 640x480, Taichi, the Phantom Kisser.png)
368 KB
368 KB PNG
>>31552594
So a Taichi-tier kiss? I'm all for it.
>>
>>31553277
>>31553297
Familiar, if you really want replaced we can do at some point. Or we could just forget about them/it/him completely.

Shotgun, well, honestly it's a little over the top, but I guess it could be done. I'd say you don't have the mana to create it yet, you'd need to do a few rolls and custom build each piece of ammo for a mana cost.

>>31553278
Oops again. +10 for both of them.
And just saying, just because there isn't a lot of Meta, doesn't mean I don't have a meta plot going.
>>
>>31553230
Thanks for running. Any idea when you'll be doing it next?
>>
>>31553230

Thanks for the run!
>>
>>31553343
Maybe Sunday, depends on when I get back from Easter with the family.

After that escapes me at the moment.


>>31553264
>>31553271
>>31553296
>>31553334
Glad you all enjoyed it.
>>
>>31553340
looking forward to when we finally break past the opening arc and fully into the plot. We're pretty close I think, maybe two more days of actual class tops
>>
>>31553340

To be honest, I would expect the shotgun to be a largely comedic thing.

Like, Mook disposal. Nobody who's actually competent should fall for it more than once, unless we surprise them with it. Beyond a certain point of effort, it just stops being worth it entirely.

Thanks anyway, and thanks for running. It was as good as usual.
>>
>>31553319

I kind of expected his to play a bigger part (I voted for him in the beginning)

He hasn't been summoned ever.
>>
>>31553372
We can always spend protag points to make it happen earlier, you know. Plot hooks usually require investment regardless.
>>
>>31553340
Wait, so they're both at 26 now? Nice.
>>
>>31553371
Guide, can we make an enchanted device that delivers a bullshit escape method each time, randomly generated by you, for your own amusement? Imagine as we sail off into the sunset on a giant, inflatable rubber duck, or hand a girl attempting to kidnap us a note from our mother stating that we're really not up for it today, but we'll be better by the end of the week.
>"Finally John, you're in my clutches."
>1d100
>"BRB, Soup."
>>
>>31553340
>Oops again. +10 for both of them.
That's how much we got for kissing Chris on the cheek with a cheesy line.

Damn Chris for being so easy.
>>
>>31553387
he has been summoned once. vote was to keep him too. but the anti familiar faction kept on voting to desummon him until nobody bothered replying to them and they won with 2 votes for unsummon and 7 votes for doing something else but not specifying specifically to keep him summoned.
>>
>>31553319
>>31553387

Different tastes.

I wasn't here for that vote, otherwise I would've voted against it. I actually kinda don't want to touch summoning magic exclusively because it means having to deal with Jenkins.

You like, I no like. We will vote accordingly.
>>
>>31553457
There's always one who just doesn't know any more
>>
>>31553484
I want jenkins to be a mask. Eventually, if we get good enough at summoning we find out it's actually a sword waifu
>>
>>31553484
>I wasn't here for that vote
I wasn't here for that vote either and i would have voted for him
>>
>>31553460

He's gimmicky as hell and designed to be as irritating as possible.

If I encountered a show with something like Jenkins popping up even one time, I would drop it even if it was a masterpiece every other step of the way.

I'm kinda upset it means ruining someone else's fun, but I can't stand having Jenkins around. He can't stay and allow me to derive any enjoyment from this shit. He either needs to be gone or different.
>>
>>31553519
>seeing people run with my sword waifu idea
heh.

well, jenkins could gain the ability to turn into a sword.
and for waifu... could be jenkins was actually a girl all along and we didn't know because dead. she pretended to be male and her personality was overcompensating to appear male. but then we get her resurrected from skeleton.

or maybe what jenkins said about being a whole skeleton and we being too weak to summon entire body is true, and eventually we summon whole skeleton, then skeleton with blood vessels, then flesh (mmm, curves like a woman), then skin
>>
>>31553590
I think you're stretching too far. you're trying to make a bad idea not bad, which is good, but you're going into implausible territory.
>>
File: 1397805306072.jpg-(67 KB, 489x800, jenkins true form.jpg)
67 KB
67 KB JPG
>>31553590
I envisioned it more like pic related just trolling us because she knew how annoying we found jenkins
>>
I think a summoned buddy cop sword would be awesome. Like Michaels sword or some shit; "Back when I was palling around with Arthur..."
"You mean being weilded?"
"Do I look like a fucking stick to you?"
>>
>>31553577
maybe he is just annoying us on purpose because we suck so bad and if we forge a bond with him he will turn into a bro as well and "drop the annoying act"
>>
>>31553621

That would actually piss me off more than some people get angry at the one ninja chick.

I'm not really a Jenkins fan, but I would vote to drop that like it was on fire if they were deliberately being that irritating to fuck with us.

Familiars are supposed to be trusted partners, like a piece of ourself. Betraying trust of that level puts you at the top of the 'fuck off' list.
>>
>>31553621
>jenkins true form.
I think you mean jenkins sexy daughter who takes his place after something unfortunate happens to him
>>
I think it would be hilarious if you guys all decided to spend precious protagonist points making what would be a bit character more likable.
>>
>>31553664
this I can deal with
>>
>>31553659
>Betraying trust
wut

I have to say you sound pretty humorless.
>>
>>31553647

To me that's worse than if he was just irritating. Deliberately being an ass for sucking at the thing he basically exists to help us with makes him worthless to me.

>>31553664

Something unfortunate. Like our fist.

>>31553674

I'm fine with leaving Jenkins unsummoned forever. I'm happy as long as Jenkins isn't on screen. Dead, replaced, ignored, traded off to someone else, don't care. All equally good.
>>
>>31553664
like us doing enchantment bullshit to swap him with Junko's familliar, who turns out to be Yoruichi?
>>
>>31553686
He has a point. A familiar is going to be a being that's with you the rest of your natural life. There's an explicit bond there between the two of you, and if he's ripping the shit out of you because he knows you can't get rid of him, he's a little piece of shit.
>>
>>31553714
So you're saying he's ripe for a character arc?
>>
I like jenkins.
and the way I figured it, he is being a dick to us because we haven't befriended him yet. Also we are being a dick to him too. If we make friends he would ease up on us. OR we could stop having a colossal stick shoved up our ass and start taking his ribbing in stride. he probably doesn't mean any harm by them and is just how it makes friends

>>31553714
please properly follow the links you reply to

the trust betrayel was "if jenkins was a hot girl pretending to be a male skull to troll us"

>>31553729
exactly
>>
>>31553714
No, not really. Being a smartass in a fairly harmless way is what friends do. Presuming on this explicit bond you're talking about doesn't seem out of character for a being that's probably ageless and has done this shit over and over.
>>
Jenkins would be the best possible sentient.
>>
>>31553744
>ribbing
Heh.
>>
>>31553686

I have a sense of humor, I just also have a less than zero tolerance for certain things.

Our familiar deliberately obstructing us and being irritating for being bad at the thing he's supposed to be helping us with goes beyond 'dickish' and starts edging into 'treachery'.

Being bad at your job? Whatever. Not being particularly likeable? tolerable. Deliberately making things worse because 'ha ha fuck you'? They can fuck right off.

>>31553729

If he pulls that shit, he gets the boot. If he has some way of spending points to make himself less objectively horrible and comes back to us a changed man, letting him back in is a possibility.

If we're expected to spend points to make him less of a fuckwit, then he can stay gone.

>>31553744

>nicer to Jenkins

He opened with being a dick. If he wasn't willing to even give it a try, then I donn't see how we're obligated to hold the olive branch out for him like it was our fault our famaliar has an attitude problem.
>>
>>31553744
What if we knew and that was just how they showed up in public to avoaid confusion/afoid having to get dressed
>>
>>31553809
>Deliberately making things worse
yeah, not seeing it.

Trolling us into thinking she's a skull is not actually affecting performance in any way.
>>
>>31553809
I think that we had summoned him before the first time we summoned him in the quest, if that makes any sense
>>
>>31553853

Not that guy, but I think if our familiar is irritating to the point where some of us consider him/her useless and have banished them to the box to never be used..... That's not helping things. Especially since familiars are supposed to be something we can rely on.

>>31553867

We had. We also had a notable in character dread for summoning him again because he was just as irritating on prior occasions.
>>
Well to be fair to Jenkin's we suck so bad at summoning that it's probably fairly annoying to him to be summoned with little to no power. He is literally not all there and incomplete. If every time you got summoned you were only a head with no torso or limbs you would be a little testy too. Plus the relationship seemed to be equally antagonistic on both sides.


[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post [File Only] Password
Style
[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k] [s4s] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / adv / an / asp / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / out / po / pol / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / x] [Settings] [Home]
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

- futaba + yotsuba -
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.